Album Review: ‘Romance’ by Fontaines D.C.

Since emerging with their debut Dogrel in 2019, Fontaines D.C. have been steadily establishing themselves as the most exciting band on the indie scene, if not the planet. In the five years since their breakthrough, the Irish post-punks have been on a tireless relay between touring and recording, producing four studio albums in nearly as many years – not to mention lead singer Grian Chatten’s 2023 solo album. And yet, with their newest album, the band show no sign of fatigue. Far from it, Romance is quite possibly the most energetic and sonically vibrant record Fontaines have ever produced.

Refusing to be tied to any one sound, the album moves breathlessly between the buoyant indie-rock highs of ‘Favourite’ and the nu-metal feel of tracks like ‘Starburster’ and ‘Here’s the Thing’. On brooding album opener ‘Romance’, a heavy industrial soundscape is set against Chatten’s crooning refrain: ‘maybe romance is a place for me and you’. It’s this juxtaposed clash of sacred and profane which lies at the heart of the record. The major theme of the album may not be an especially well-kept secret but its bluntly straightforward title belies the nuance of its take on modern love. Romance is an album of tortured yearning which revels in the anguish of infatuation.

“It’s this juxtaposed clash of sacred and profane which
lies at the heart of the record”

In a series of vignettes, the band examine the trials and tribulations of 21st century love in all its grim reality. On ‘Bug’, a faithless lover feels the sting of loneliness, promising to apologise for ‘the remainder of my life’, whilst on ‘Motorcycle Boy’, the titular figure warns of his own untrustworthiness, ‘you rain, I snow. You stay, I’ll go’. The shoegaze-inspired ‘Sundowner’, the first Fontaines track to not feature Chatten on lead vocals, calls on us to escape into its landscape of mellow fantasy. The darkest track on the album, the grunge-suffused ‘Death Kink’, tells the story of a doomed relationship and a lover told he’d ‘love the chain’. The course of true love doesn’t run smooth for Fontaines, but the journey through the rough of tortured relationships is necessary in leading us towards the album’s central thesis: when it comes to romance, as Chatten repeatedly says, ‘it may feel bad’. But it is the gloomy depths of the album which allow its ecstatic highs to shine all the brighter.

“The shoegaze-inspired ‘Sundowner’, the first
Fontaines track to not feature Chatten on lead vocals, calls on us to escape into its landscape of mellow fantasy”

Album closer ‘Favourite’, an instant indie classic, resolves the album’s tortured ennui into sunlit melancholy. Buoyed by a brightly simple guitar riff and kinetic drum line, the song takes nostalgia in its stride, looking back on youth and love in all its bittersweetness, casually reflecting that ‘you’ve been my favourite for a long time’.

Unsurprising for a band who were writing poetry before they started writing songs, literary references abound throughout Romance. Jack Kerouac’s beatnik hero Sal Paradise makes a cameo on ‘In the Modern World’ while the track ‘Horseness is the Whatness’ borrows its title from James Joyce’s Ulysses, the seminal epic of Irish literature. It is this literate attitude to rock and roll which sets Fontaines apart from so many of their contemporaries. Among the grand pantheon of indie bands, they are equal parts The Smiths and Oasis, caring as much about filling stadiums as they do about reading them poetry.

“Jack Kerouac’s beatnik hero Sal Paradise makes a cameo on ‘In the Modern World’ while the track ‘Horseness is the Whatness’ borrows its title from James Joyce’s Ulysses, the seminal epic of Irish literature”

With dates lined up around the world for the next year, culminating in a headline show at Finsbury Park in July supported by the republican hip-hop group Kneecap, Fontaines look primed for world domination. In a genre perpetually caught in the death throes of nostalgia – never quite getting over Arctic Monkeys abandoning their guitars for pianos – Fontaines D.C. stand out as a band genuinely striving to push indie music forward, with Romance making only clearer their position as the vanguards of British and Irish guitar music. Way back on Dogrel’s opening track, Fontaines promised that they were going to be ‘big’ and, after Romance, it seems like they’ve made good on that promise.

Image credits: Lulu Lin