The Tragedy Bias

By Matthew Dodd

When the then-former President Donald Trump was shot at a rally in Pennsylvania last July, the incumbent Joe Biden – his then-rival for the Presidency – addressed the nation in sombre tones, imploring Americans to “lower the temperature in our politics”. He continued that “political rhetoric in this country has gotten very heated” and that, regardless of disagreement, “we are not enemies.” That Trump survived his shooting was a random accident of chance, and Biden clearly understood that the near-miss needed to be treated with all the severity of a successful assassination. When the right-wing activist Charlie Kirk was shot dead in Utah in September, President Trump was asked by Fox News how he hoped to bring a divided nation together in the wake of tragedy. His response:”I’ll tell you something that is going to get me in trouble, but I couldn’t care less.” Instead of foregrounding the need for unity, togetherness and peaceability, Trump blamed in the first of his many addresses on Kirk’s shooting “radical left political violence”. In an address from the Oval Office, Trump recalled a litany of so-called left-wing political violence perpetrated in recent years – attacks on ICE agents, the assassination of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson and Trump’s own attempted shooting – alongside which Kirk’s counted. Notably absent from his recollections were those recent instances of political violence against prominent Democrats: the attack on Paul Pelosi, the arson of Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro’s residence, the assassination of Minnesota state legislator Melissa Hortman in July. Indeed, when asked whether he ought to have ordered federal flags flown at half-mast after Hortman’s assassination, Trump replied that he was ‘not familiar’ with her – he had elected to miss the funeral, also. 

The reaction to Charlie Kirk’s assassination by the American right has been, in no small part, an attempt to assert total ideological control under the smokescreen of tragedy. The death of a supposed free-speech advocate has been a recourse for the United States government to crack down on dissenting voices nationwide. In the same speech where President Trump praised Kirk as a ‘fearless warrior for liberty’, he promised to use the full instruments of the federal government to squash left-wing organisations, publications and groups. In the last weeks, foreign nationals have had visas revoked for suggesting Kirk was anything less than a hero, Jimmy Kimmel was suspended from television for – not unfoundedly – alluding to the MAGA movement’s desperate attempts to distance Kirk’s killer from themselves (the Utah Governor told press that he was praying the killer wasn’t ‘one of us’), and Oklahoma’s Governor has announced the mandatory establishment of Turning Point USA chapters in every high school across the state. How, then, to reconcile honouring a man’s murder in the name of free speech with a nationwide effort to squash free political expression? Trump may have shown his hand too freely in this regard when he suggested that October 14th should be declared a ‘National Day of Remembrance for Charlie Kirk’. Keen political memories will recall another recent martyr who shared this birthday: George Floyd. 

Why, then, does a force which controls congress, the judiciary and the presidency, feel the need to portray themselves as the underdogs?

American conservatives have been waiting for their own Black Lives Matter moment since 2020. The political reaction to Floyd’s death, a moment of national reckoning and an overall rebuttal of Trump’s first-term philosophy, was a blow against the American right which they clearly haven’t recovered from. Kirk’s death, therefore, has been the moment for which they’ve been waiting: a chance to paint themselves as the persecuted minority, and a chance to chase retribution. The sinister element at play is that, unlike in 2020, this movement is not positioned against authority – the BLM movement became distinctly anti-Trump and played no small part in his defeat – but rather is closely aligned with a force already in power. Why, then, does a force which controls congress, the judiciary and the presidency, feel the need to portray themselves as the underdogs? Like so much of Trump’s second term, the motive seems solely to achieve further control, to establish an ideological dominance immune to criticism, opposition and, quite possibly, removal. From blockbuster stadium funerals to posthumous medals of freedom, Trump has been keen to keep Kirk’s death as alive in the public consciousness as he can, justifying ever-broader attacks on the freedom of speech Kirk claimed to stand for. 

Regardless of Kirk’s controversial and largely reprehensible views, his death was unnecessary and tragic. Nevertheless, he was one of over 11,000 gun deaths so far in the US this year and one of an increasing number of political figures killed for their views – no others of whom have had their faces proposed for US currency. This is all without mentioning 20,000 children killed in Gaza, none of whom have warranted such public outpourings of executive grief. Violence has become a fact of political life. Across the pond, political violence is proliferating on all sides; an American Years of Lead seems to be upon us. To take partisan aim, suggesting that violence moves solely from left-to-right, is not just fallacious, but a dangerous tool of political repression. If we mourn Charlie Kirk, we must mourn all those killed for their views and confront not a political ideology but a culture of violence which has been allowed to blossom in recent years. Politicising violence does nothing but stoke the fires of division, the same fires which killed Charlie Kirk, Melissa Hortman, and risk spreading all across the nation. 

Image by Gage Skidmore via Wikimedia Commons