When you take the top guy out: Maduro and ‘El Mencho’
By Archie Phillips
Eight weeks after Nicolás Maduro’s successful extraction by US military forces, the democratic situation in Venezuela remains largely unchanged.
The American military left the country as soon as it had arrived on the night of January 3rd, leaving the Vice President of Maduro’s regime, Delcy Rodriguez, in place as acting leader. The administration concluded it would be the preferable situation to avoid violence and allow the easiest access to Venezuela’s oil reserves. There are no prizes for guessing what factor got top billing when that decision was made.
But Rodriguez is far from a vestigial remnant of a despotic regime. Walk into the National Assembly building in Caracas at some point this week and you would find Maduro’s interior minister and defence minister, among other key figures of his reign.
Even still, Maduro – the same leader who imprisoned over 2,400 people in 2024 to silence allegations of election fraud – is in custody in America. Venezuelans, emboldened by Maduro’s arrest and the release of 440 political prisoners, are expecting a return to democracy soon; but will their hopes be realised?
What the operations share is the unanswered, and likely unconsidered, question of: what happens to the country’s ordinary people?
Rodriguez has paid lip service to the idea, but has declined to say when free and fair elections would be held. Her brother, the National Assembly chief, Jorge Rodriguez, rejected the idea that Presidential elections would be held anytime soon. Still, “the oil is coming out and a lot of money is being made”, said Trump on February 20th.
The story of how regime change has been enacted by the Trump administration in Venezuela is plain. Various chokeholds were applied to the country. A precise and ultimately impressive strike to take out the leader followed. Once the military had done its job, America clapped its hands together and turned around with a wilful abandonment of practical detail that might otherwise have moved the country towards democratic reform.
In many ways, the same pattern has followed with the CIA-Mexico joint mission to take out Mexico’s most powerful drug lord. On February 22nd, Nemesio Oseguera Cervantes, known as “El Mencho”in Mexico, died after an assault by the authorities who tracked him to the Talpapa Country Club. He was head of the brutal Jalisco New Generation Cartel (CJNG) which controls most of the territory in Mexico.
Mexico’s President, Claudia Sheinbaum came to power in 2024 on the promise she would continue ‘the abrazos, no balazos’ (‘hugs, not bullets’) of her predecessor, which rejected confrontation with Mexico’s powerful cartels in favour of strengthening state institutions. Unhappy with her approach, Trump threatened 25% tariffs on Mexico in February 2025 saying they ought to do more to crack down on the criminal cartels that lay down the law in Mexico’s cities. Just over a year later, the Mexican government, aided by CIA intelligence and a US Predator drone, took out Mexico’s most notorious cartel leader.
Unlike the operation in Venezuela, there can be no accusations of a disregard for international law here; the American military was not even directly involved on the ground. What it does share with those operations is the unanswered, and likely unconsidered, question of: what happens to the country’s ordinary people?
Removing the kingpin does not take out the regime, and the precedent shows that a violent splintering of factions arises in the power vacuum left
Removing the kingpin does not take out the regime, and in Mexico’s case the precedent shows that a violent splintering of factions usually arises in the power vacuum left. CNJG itself benefitted from the war within the Sinaloa Cartel after its leader, Joaquín “El Chapo” Guzmán, was extradited to the US in 2017. The authorities have been unable to contain Sinaloa violence in the affected states. Immediately after El Mencho’s death, violent shows of loyalty from his cartel’s members against the authorities were reported in at least 20 of the country’s 32 states.
With the kingpin taken out, this may be enough for Trump, and President Sheinbaum may have staved off further talk of the need for unilateral US military action. But like Venezuela, the removal of the leader of a brutal regime does not guarantee the improvement of the country. Instead, without a clear plan for how to move after the operation, the situation is prone to stay the same, or in Mexico’s case, become subsumed by irrepressible violence between warring factions of the CJNG.
At the house El Mencho was staying at before he was killed, Mexican journalists found a handwritten summary of Psalm 91: “A thousand may fall dead beside you, ten thousand all around you, but you will not be harmed’.
America’s strangulations and intelligence have been successful in removing the man at the top. But with a lack of regard for detail, they have not gone much further, and in Mexico’s case, may only increase the violence of the cartels.
Image: U.S. Army via Wikimedia Commons

