Pay Rises, Pay Restorations: resident doctors’ persistent dispute with Wes Streeting
By Archie Phillips
On the 14th of November, a 5-day strike by resident doctors – formerly known as junior doctors – will go ahead across the country. It will be the 13th walkout since March 2023, in a dispute over pay which has been an implacable obstacle for the Health Secretary, Wes Streeting.
The latest round of strikes follows a fresh offer made by Streeting in a letter to the British Medical Association (BMA) last Wednesday, having met union leaders the day before. Its dismissal by the BMA leaves the Government at a crossroads: an upcoming budget with around a £30bn hole in the public finances, meanwhile resident doctors still demand higher pay and an improvement of job conditions and opportunities.
In his latest proposal, Streeting promised a number of actions to improve the career promises and working conditions of resident doctors, but refused to reopen pay negotiations. He promised an extra 2000 specialist training places for doctors finishing their foundation course – only 1000 were initially pledged in the 10-year NHS plan in the summer. He also offered to cover mandatory exam and membership fees, responding to the unions’ growing concerns of the excessive private costs that doctors face. Recently, the National Institute for Health found the average unreimbursed cost for a junior graduate exceeds £18,000.
”In his latest proposal, Streeting promised a number of actions to improve the career promises and working conditions of resident doctors, but refused to reopen pay negotiations”
On pay, Streeting was firm, saying that: “We’ve been really clear we can’t open this year’s pay award; it’s unreasonable to push for more at this stage.” Public opinion on the dispute remains divided. For many, sympathy is waning at a time where both private and public sector workers are feeling the squeeze of the cost of living on their salaries, and are anxious about their employment generally. Moreover, resident doctors receive 23.7% from the state towards their pension, the highest contribution in the public sector.
By contrast, Streeting’s line that they have enjoyed “the highest pay award in the public sector” is disputed by resident doctors who point to the 2% decrease of their salaries in real terms over the last 4 years. In their view, their demands are for a pay restoration, which recognises their inordinate student debts (usually between £80-100,000 when they graduate), unsociable hours, and constant relocation because of rigid training programmes.
In order to return their salaries to 2008 levels, the government would have to keep their pay in line with inflation for a decade – something MP’s salaries have achieved already. “This is a political choice not to pay doctors appropriately,” said Dr Mellisa Ryan on the picket line to reporters. She is the co-chairwoman of the BMA’s resident doctors committee, and has been most active in voicing their demands.
The latest proposals of Mr Streeting “do not go far enough” for the chairman of the BMA’s resident doctors committee, Dr Jack Fletcher. The 1000 extra posts promised next year falls short of the roughly 20,000 new places which are needed to meet current demand, says Dr Fletcher.
”The 1000 extra posts promised next year falls short of the roughly 20,000 new places which are needed to meet current demand,’ says Dr Fletcher”
Moreover, there is a very small pot of public money which is being spread thinly over a range of underfunded public services. As the Autumn Budget approaches, and Chancellor Rachel Reeves must balance investment with fiscal rules, these chronically underfunded institutions will continue to have to do more with less. Critics have argued that the stark day-to-day reality across public services as a whole give rise to accusations of ingratitude and a lack of awareness from resident doctors.
At the root of the industrial action, however, is the sense that resident doctors want to be treated like qualified professionals, not university freshers living in subsidized flats on £18 an hour. It’s perhaps this issue of their feeling relegated and unappreciated which is pushing the surge in emigration for medical professionals in the United Kingdom. Recently, a survey found one in three doctors to say they are ‘likely’ to relocate abroad within the next 12 months. This is an issue which successive governments have had to contend with and depletes the NHS of key domestic talent.
In County Durham and the North East over the coming days, patients are being asked to choose services wisely, and use 111 for most health needs, only using 999 for life threatening emergencies. Patients are being told to attend currently booked appointments, although some elective care and outpatient appointments are due to be postponed and rearranged in order to continue emergency care services.
Image: Roger Blackwell via Wikimedia Commons
Image: Roger Blackwell via Wikimedia Commons

