Tourette’s and the limits of empathy

By William Lock

Have you ever found yourself standing on a steep ledge when an intrusive thought enters your mind: “Imagine if I jumped right now?” Or stood talking to someone and thought ‘Can you imagine how bad it would be if I said that right now?” For most of us these are nothing more than momentary unconscious thoughts, immediately dismissed by the rational part of our brains; they are of no consequence beyond a slight residual shudder as we contemplate what just might have happened if we actually went through with them. For those disabled by Tourette’s, however, it’s not nearly that simple.

John Davidson, whose life is chronicled in the BAFTA award-winning biography I Swear, first experienced symptoms of Tourette’s age 11, when he started involuntarily jerking his neck and spitting his food. Over time, his symptoms became more serious, progressing to Coprolalia, the unwilling utterance of socially taboo words the speaker knows will get them into trouble. While eating school lunch with his headmaster, asked what he thought of his school dinners, Davidson yelled ‘they’re fucking shite’, a comment that, in an era when it was still legal for teachers to beat pupils in schools, entitled his headmaster to whip his hands with a belt. Davidson didn’t even dislike his school dinners; much like Durham college catering deep into Easter Term, they served him chips practically every day.

From this example we can draw out two facets of Coprolalia vital for understanding the disorder and those who suffer with it. First, there is no ‘decision’ to yell obscenities; the brain simply registers that saying something would be a bad idea, and the words come out. While in court, charged with assault, staring down a potential prison sentence, Davidson repeatedly referred to the presiding judge as a ‘cunt’ amidst a failed attempt to recite the oath, an unlikely conscious choice. Second, that the content of tics does not necessarily reflect the genuine opinions and feelings of the person uttering them. Ruth Ojadi, a woman in the US with Coprolalia, yells her PIN number whenever she makes a purchase; are we to assume she has a deep, secret desire to have all her money stolen that unconsciously rears itself in public by way of a tic? That seems absurd.

Empathy may be hard-wired into the human psyche, but to understand, accept, and support when there’s no tangible benefit: that requires a conscious choice distressingly few are willing to make.

This brings us to the events of the 79th BAFTA Awards, where I Swear was nominated for a series of awards. John Davidson, as would be expected given the movie is a biography of his life, was invited to attend, leading to the now notorious incident when Davidson ticced the n-word while black actors Michael B. Jordan and Delroy Lindo presented the first award of the evening. Egregiously, the BBC chose to air the incident, broadcasting to the entire world Jordan, Lindo, and Davidson’s humiliation; Akinola Davies’s invocation of ‘free Palestine’ was deemed simply too offensive to air.

John Davidson didn’t use the language he did because of genuinely held racist beliefs. The n-word is the worst thing you can call a black person, and Coprolalia compels a person to utter the most taboo and inappropriate word in every social scenario. However, this reality could do nothing to prevent a pile on against Davidson, egged on by some of the most powerful figures in show business. Jamie Foxx, who ironically enough earned critical acclaim for his empathetic portrayal of blind musician Ray Charles, insisted that Davidson “meant that shit”, while Dean Cole, host of the NAACP Image Awards, joked that “if there are any white men…with Tourette’s…they better read the room tonight”. Davidson was once hospitalised after the boyfriend of a women he ticced at attacked him with a machete.

The willingness of multi-millionaire film stars to bully a severely disabled man illuminates a dark truth about empathy: just how transactional it can be. The film industry was willing to accept people with Tourette’s when they had much to gain and little to lose, extolling the virtues of ‘I Swear’, effusively praising its message of inclusion and understanding, all building a positive conception of the self (“I am empathetic, I am understanding”) they could virtue signal to others. It’s a lot harder to be empathetic, however, when you have nothing to gain and doing so risks a personal or social cost. 

A simple statement empathising with the harm the tic caused Jordan and Lindo, while acknowledging Davidson’s lack of intent, is the obvious moral choice, but the transaction costs are high. It risks damage to your reputation and friendships: do you really care about Davidson just as much as your friends and colleagues? Most ran the numbers and concluded it wasn’t worth it.

Empathy may be hard-wired into the human psyche, but to understand, accept, and support when there’s no tangible benefit: that requires a conscious choice distressingly few are willing to make.

Image: The web via Wikimedia Commons