MP Jonathan Hinder on Labour’s identity crisis and Burnham’s “middle-class” poll bounce

By William Lock

Andy Burnham’s elevation to the leadership of the Labour Party delivered the party both a substantial jump in the polls, the famed ‘Burnham bounce’, and a shift in ideological disposition, the party now a more proactive endorser of nationalisation, devolution, and rolling back the economic and political consensus which has caught British politics in a stranglehold since the premiership of Margaret Thatcher.

This dramatic political course-correction has shone a spotlight on the diversity of thought and opinion (dare one say factions?) which have characterised the history of the Labour Party. The disputes between the supporters of Hugh Gaitskell and Aneurin Bevan in the ‘50s, Dennis Healey and his more-radically left-wing colleagues in the ‘70s/early ‘80s, and the Corbynites and Starmerites in the modern day, all speak to a party united in its conviction to improve the lot of the common man, but unavoidably divided in their assessment of the exact course of treatment.

For this reason, I interviewed Jonathan Hinder, Labour MP for Pendle and Clitheroe since 2024, well known for his online content in support of Blue Labour, a faction of the party which fuses left-wing economics with socially conservative tendencies on certain issues.

Asked to describe Blue Labour in his own words, Jonathan spoke of a “socialist tradition within the Labour Party, tracing our roots back to when the party was first founded, radical on the economy, very much pro-worker, pro-intervention, but not the sort of social, hyper-liberals that the Labour Party’s come to be associated with. It’s that second element which marks us out from the more modern Labour Party, even though we’d see ourselves squarely in the mainstream tradition of the party.”

When I questioned Jonathan about his journey in politics, and what shaped his decision to stand in this particular tradition of the party, he argued that Blue Labour stands where “the mass of a huge number of people in the country” already are; “the political class may not be as fond of it” but “that sort of left side on economics and more moderate on the social issues like immigration and crime…is a very common middle ground that a huge number of people in the country would subscribe to.” They lack a political vehicle through which to express that, “but Blue Labour offers that, it’s just a shame that we’re not a more prominent part of the Labour Party.”

Are we an election winning machine only, or do we actually believe in something?

The arguments from Jonathan mirror a common claim from Blue Labour supporters, namely, that the party has disconnected from its traditional working-class supporters by means of an undue faith in the capability of markets to promote the common good. That, together with ‘hyper-liberal’ policy directions that cast Labour in opposition to the sensibilities of most voters and inappropriately favoured the individual at cost to the community, explain why Labour’s base of support has increasingly shifted towards the wealthy and middle-class.

I asked Jonathan where the party had gone astray, embracing ‘hyper-liberal’ policies that disconnected it from Labour’s traditional base.

“Immigration is the number one issue that has come to the fore in recent years, and where I think the Labour Party has diverged from its working-class base. If you think about the needs of the existing community, versus the needs or desires of those coming in, there’s a lack of balance there.”

He framed current thinking as “a perspective through the individual, rather than thinking about the whole community, what’s in the interest of the common good, seeing it through the individual person rather than what’s best for everybody. That’s why you see this reluctance to tackle the immigration issue, because its all about the perfectly well-meaning people who might want to come to Britain, rather than protecting community cohesion and amount of upheaval for those already here.”

I put it to Jonathan that the Labour Party had a long history of embracing socially liberal reforms that took the party out of step with general opinion, most notably the government of Harold Wilson, which abolished capital punishment and decriminalised both same-sex acts and abortion. Did this suggest social liberalisation was an integral part of Labour’s historic tradition?

“I don’t think liberalisation on those social issues is ‘hyper-liberalism’ at all, that’s the kind of moral position that Blue Labour would absolutely subscribe to and support. It’s about that balance between individual rights and the common good; we want people to be able to express themselves, but there are bounds to that because we’re all dependent on each other’s actions for the functions of society. [The examples I listed] are things the Labour Party can be proud of, and I definitely would be as well, but we’ve moved quite radically since then.”

We’re trying to build a society that everyone feels like they’ve got a stake in

I wanted to relate our conversation more specifically to the Durham context, so asked Jonathan what the Blue Labour pitch was for young students, a group more socially liberal than the country at-large and likely to live in large, cosmopolitan urban areas, a framing he described as “telling”, rejecting the notion that “the individual voter is a consumer and political parties are offering a product.”

“We’re trying to build a society that everyone feels like they’ve got a stake in, and we can have a huge range of different views, but we want to build a society where everyone can express themselves within certain bounds and do well out of it. There’s a bit of a caricature about what Blue Labour is; having controls over immigration and loving the country, believing that family bonds are incredibly important, these are just normal values that most people would hold.”

Jonathan rejected the assertion Blue Labour had nothing to offer young people, attributing great interest among a generation that “hadn’t grown up in those benign, end of century circumstances, and might want a bit of a reset”, referencing the broad political consensus during the late ‘90s and early noughties in favour of free market economics and globalisation, best optimised by Francis Fukuyama’s book ‘the End of History’, which asserted that liberal democracy and free-market economics constituted the definitive, final form of human government.

Jonathan was keen to get across just how long Blue Labour had been advocating for more radical economic change, telling me it had “been much more radical on the economy than the Labour Party had been for quite some time”.

“In terms of wanting to push back against the neoliberal consensus, we’ve been talking about this long before the new Prime Minister arrived and very happily took it on; the reindustrialisation agenda, regional inequality, all of these things people associated with Blue Labour have been talking about for a long time.”

Towards the end of the interview, I brought up the question of who now constituted the base of the Labour Party – those voters most likely to consistently back the party election after election whatever the party’s standing in the rest of the country. Did this core constituency now consist of financially insecure urban graduates, instead of the ‘red wall’ working class communities, oriented around traditional heavy industry and manual labour, and how could Labour change this, if it was desirable to do so at all?

Jonathan expressed “no doubt that Labour’s electoral base has shifted – we’ve seen some of the polling at the moment which suggests you’re most likely to vote for Labour if you went to private school or if you’re in the better off income brackets. We’ve definitely got work to do to reconnect with our working-class base.  I always come back to the question of what are we for; are we an election winning machine only, or do we actually believe in something?”

Jonathan was excoriating of “the idea of just giving up and saying we should chase after the people who are actually nothing like the people we used to represent, and we’re actually for the wealthy middle classes in the cities who are actually doing quite well for themselves. That seems to me a very odd position to take.”

In his view, a further strengthening of Labour’s new middle-class base was responsible for the party’s bounce in the polls since Burnham’s ascension to the leadership: “Under the new leadership we’ve really shored up that new middle-class base and now the hard work starts of trying to turn back to face our traditional working base, which I think Burnham has the capacity to do. He very much comes from an area like that and understands how we’ve drifted apart.”

“If the Labour Party is worth something, it should be trying to have those people, represent those people, not patronise them, tell them they’re wrong, sneer at them.”

Image Credit: ©House of Commons / Laurie Noble