What does Cameron’s second term hold for the UK?
By Will Fremont-Barnes

As Tony Blair savoured his comprehensive re-election as prime minister in 2001, the Cabinet Secretary, Sir Richard Wilson, issued him with the following warning: “you are now at the peak of your powers. You may never be as strong again as you are now”. The same is true of David Cameron, the self-styled ‘heir to Blair’, as he celebrates an unlikely overall Conservative majority that represents a clear endorsement of his record.
There can be no argument about legitimacy this time. Whereas in 2010 he owed his majority in the House of Commons to a marriage of convenience with the Liberal Democrats, Cameron’s party now commands a working majority of its own, ruthlessly stealing seats from their former coalition partner as big-hitters such as Vince Cable, David Laws and Ed Davey were defeated. The Conservatives have taken all of the credit from the coalition whilst the Lib Dems have been reduced to single digits, in what truly has been a harrowing repeat of what George Dangerfield famously described as ‘the strange death of liberal England’.
As a result, Cameron is stronger than at any point during his five years as prime minister, seemingly able to fulfil his pledge of serving a full second term. There will be little appetite for a mid-parliament leadership change. The public would take a dim view if the first Tory leader to deliver a majority for nearly a quarter of a century was replaced by Boris Johnson or Theresa May in 2017. Just as Thursday was a terrible night for Labour and the Lib Dems, the scale of victory was also a setback for those Tories with their eyes fixed on the leadership.
Cameron is the man in possession for the foreseeable future. He framed the vote as a referendum on his government’s handling of the economy, warning that any administration led by Ed Miliband would undo many of its policies and put at risk the recovery that had been secured by painful austerity measures. Labour’s crude, though not entirely inaccurate, portrayal of the Tories as the nasty party had little impact as Cameron’s campaign continued to emphasise the importance of fiscal responsibility.
Having convinced the British people of his ability to steer the country through choppy economic waters, the major test of Cameron’s second term will be how he proceeds if the deficit is reduced and the financial situation improves. His premiership up until now has been all about, to parrot his own words, clearing up the mess left behind by the previous Labour government, but there will eventually come a time when Cameron is required to do more than simply preside over a growing economy.
The early indications are that this will be a slightly different Conservative government in tone and ambition. In recognition of the Scottish National Party’s extraordinary performance north of the border, a phenomenon that Labour has accused Cameron of encouraging with his claims that Nicola Sturgeon would pull the strings in the event of a hung parliament, the prime minister will have to rise to the challenge of preserving the United Kingdom. Presiding over the breakup of the Union would have a profoundly negative impact on Cameron’s pride and legacy. Aligning himself with the ‘one nation’ conservative tradition may sound like political posturing, but it is necessary if he has any hope of reaching out to the Scots.
Britain’s relationship with the European Union is also likely to cast a significant shadow over Cameron’s second term. His unprecedented power as a newly returned prime minister would be well used by opening talks with Brussels to renegotiate EU membership. Cameron has sufficient leverage to gain as many concessions as is possible, and it will be politically tricky for Eurosceptic Conservative backbenchers to criticise whatever deal he strikes without undermining the government.
Assuming that Cameron’s second term is not brought to a premature end by the disintegration of the UK or infighting within the party over Europe, the prime minister has the opportunity to go considerably further with his cuts to tax and welfare than he did during the previous parliament. Whilst a commitment to scaling down the size of the state may remove bureaucratic inefficiencies, the idea that it will not eventually harm public services is naïve in the extreme. His mandate for such policies, however, is now beyond dispute.
Yet Cameron is more idealistic than those Thatcherites who judge success solely by numbers. Rightly or wrongly, Cameron has considered spending cuts as the only solution to the global financial crisis, a dramatic u-turn to his pre-2008 view that the Tories should match the Labour government’s spending levels. Once the government’s much-heralded recovery is complete, there is every reason to assume that the energetic Cameron who rose to the party’s leadership promising compassionate conservatism will re-emerge. His willingness to engage with social issues will increase if he is freed from constantly fretting about dire economic ramifications.
Having pulled off a remarkable electoral feat, Cameron is at the very peak of his powers. In the interests of being remembered as more than just a prudent accountant, he would be wise to press ahead with meaningful changes whilst his stock remains high.
Photograph: Creative Commons
