Genevieve Wood on Obamacare, 2016 and the Special Relationship

By Will Fremont-Barnes

Genevieve Wood works for Heritage, a conservative think tank in Washington DC, and regularly appears on US television networks as an analyst. In this interview, she explains what her role entails and gives her take on the major political issues of the day.

genevieve wood

What does the Heritage Foundation do?

Heritage has been around for just over forty years; we were founded in 1973. We are a think-tank, and what that means is that we develop policy ideas, in our case on a whole host of issues, including domestic policy: economics taxes,welfare, but also deals with issues such as marriage, abortion policy, education. Then we deal with both national security and defence policy and trade: what the size of our military should be, what our relations should be around the world, what American leadership looks like. We have scholars on just about any issue; you name it we’ve probably got at least one person in the building who’s an expert on that particular issue! We develop ideas, both on how the government could run better, how government could get out of the way and let the private sector do its job, and we provide those ideas to members of Congress. We don’t lobby them but we do give them legislative ideas that we can back up with studies, with statistical data that shows how we think a particular idea, or a piece of legislation, will affect the American people.

Obamacare has come in for a lot of criticism, but isn’t it similar to a proposed Heritage healthcare plan?

We’re a think tank and we’ve had a lot of ideas go through the halls of this building at different times, but it just isn’t true that the ideas of the Heritage Foundation were adopted by Obamacare. If it was, I think we would be supporting more of it. What Heritage said we were for was for states to try their own systems, and what was happening back then was that the state of Massachusetts wanted to try its own healthcare system, not forcing all 49 other states to do the exact same thing, but to do their own model and see how that worked. Fortunately some of the ideas we had played out in the state of Massachusetts, and some of them didn’t, because there were people like Ted Kennedy who wanted more of a government centralised role. So those who want to compare the two, I think they have to really sit down and look at them, and they’ll see they’re not quite the same idea.

Has the lurch to the right been a good thing for the Republican Party?

No matter what political party you’re part of, I would hope that principles are the foundation of what you stand for. What you’re seeing in the Republican Party right now is those who believe in more limited government, who believe that the government has gotten too big, invades too many areas of our day-to-day lives. It’s not just how high are our taxes, but the role of government in telling people how they should educate their children, and what schools ought to be teaching. That used to be a very localised type of decision. People have concerns with laws and regulations that make it very hard for businesses to start, particularly small businesses. So I think people have risen up in recent years, many of them through the Tea Party. Obamacare, legislation being put through that nationalised the American healthcare system, which is anathema in this country, was a real shocker. A lot of people stood up and said ‘wait a minute, government’s getting too big’, their voices had been heard in the Republican Party more than anywhere else, and has it pulled the party to the right? I think so, but I don’t think that’s necessarily a bad thing. I think it’s making the Republicans true to what they say they’re for.

Was the midterm election a referendum on the President?

I do think it was a referendum on some of the things the President has done. I don’t think there’s any doubt about that. Things like Obamacare, his executive moves on issue over illegal immigration to this country, he didn’t get what he wanted in Congress so he just went around them and signed off his own executive orders. That concerned people, even those in the middle who voted for him before, that he was getting a little bit too big for his pants. We don’t have kings in this country we have presidents, and people were getting concerned about where he was headed. Regardless of what numbers people want to pull out, most Americans don’t feel like the economy is where it needs to be. They don’t feel as though they’re any further ahead than they were six years ago when President Obama came into office. That affects the way people think, and the way they vote.

Would you agree that Obama is liked but not feared?

I wasn’t interested in having a president who wants to win popularity contests. I would love the people of the UK to like our president, but more than anything I would like people around the world who want to do bad things to America to fear our president. A concern that many Americans also have today is that we’re not feared, and that President Obama’s not as tough as he needs to be against the Islamic militants. We’re no safer today than we were when he came into office, and there’s some concern that we’re not on it in the way that we were for example under George W. Bush. He seems like a nice man, a good father, but that’s not your job as president to win popularity contests, it’s to protect the country, and I think there’s some concern that he’s not up to that job and doesn’t want to be up to that job as much as he should.

How damaging do you think that Senate report on torture was both for the country’s security and for its credibility?

It was interesting how a lot of Americans took that, which was, ‘we’ve got to defend American lives, and if we have bad guys in jail who are going to tell us stuff, we need to do what we need to do to get that information out of them’. I think there were also questions about the timing of the release of that report. This is something that’s been around for a while, if things had really crossed the line why were we just now hearing about it? The rest of the world, they’re going to have to take it how they do, but I don’t think anybody can say that America doesn’t normally come to their side when that’s needed, and that they don’t want America as a partner in fighting the bad guys around the world.

How would you assess the state of race relations in the US at present?

We would all love to think that they will be perfect but we don’t live in a perfect world. President Obama is someone who’s elected twice. America is not a predominantly African-American country, so you had a lot of white folks who voted for a black man for president. I think that says a lot more about the state of race relations than when you see riots break out amongst smaller populations and groups. That’s not to say that everything that’s happened has been perfect, but I don’t think the rest of the country saw what’s happened in New York or what’s happened in Missouri in the way a few people saw it, and really tried to turn it into something. When you look at what the larger public does, they voted a black man into office, so I think that you have to look at all the scenarios, not just one incident.

You’ve questioned Jeb Bush’s conservative credentials, but how do you rate his chances of winning the Republican nomination?

Right now he’s the guy who’s put the most out there saying ‘I’m gonna run’, and the polls show that he’s at the front of the pack. One of the questions I have is: which Jeb Bush will stand up? Will it be the one who was governor of Florida? Or will it be the one who over the past several years has seemed to move in the wrong direction on a couple of issues. There’s no doubt he’s a serious candidate. The question will be who else gets into the race, how many get into the race. How many people like Ted Cruz will jump in? There’s a lot of governors that I’m sure people in the UK may not be familiar with, that some people in America aren’t familiar with, but once they get out there, Americans kinda like new things! The idea that someone who’s currently unknown can’t make a difference, well, Barack Obama didn’t follow that vice. Nobody knew who he was in this country two or three years before he ran for president. He was that new guy from Illinois, and he became president.

Given that Hillary Clinton looks likely to be the Democratic nominee, how significant would it be for the US to have its first female president?

I don’t care what sex a person is in the White House; I care what their policies are. While it may be neat to say, ‘oh it’s the first woman president’, there have been a lot of very strong women leaders. You all know one very well, Margaret Thatcher, who was phenomenal in my view. If we had a Margaret Thatcher running in this country, I’d be going gang-busters for her, but not because she’s a woman, but because she was a strong leader with strong principles who had good ideas for the country at the time. If there’s somebody like that, it shouldn’t matter what the colour of their skin is, what sex they are. Hillary’s been around for a while, so she’s not new. She may be a woman but she’s not a new woman.

Finally, do you sense a change in the special relationship between the United States and the Great Britain since the Blair-Bush era?

I don’t think it’s changed in terms of how we feel about you all. Sometimes I don’t think we give as much prominence to that relationship as we should. I certainly don’t think President Obama has as much as former presidents, recognising the shared connections, the shared history, between these two countries. We saw some of that when President Obama came in and sent gifts back, which frankly was extremely rude. I think most Americans have good thoughts about Great Britain and I think it’s important those two countries keep their ties. When it comes to these challenges that we face now around the world, it’s going to take a number of countries, certainly the UK, certainly the US, making sure that we are standing together against these forces.

Photograph: Genevieve Wood