War has already been declared on us; now let’s work out how to win it
By Oscar Rocklin
The public debate on dealing with Islamic State and approaching the issue of airstrikes in Syria is all wrong.
On the one hand, there is the case made by NUS student politico-types or overgrown versions like Jeremy Corbyn who, admirable though they are in their commitment to cause, naively stonewall anything resembling military action, whatever the context. Yet, these same people also have the temerity to constantly claim that they are the champions of the millions tragically dispossessed by a war they have no strategy to help end. Online harping on about how “the United States is the world’s biggest exporter of terror” or sharing some vapid Facebook event about how they care equally about Paris and Beirut demonstrates the self-congratulatory and masturbatory nature of much that is said.
In and amongst all this guff, there are a number of real arguments to address. These include variations on the phrase “we created this situation in the first place… how will more bombs make us secure?” It is absolutely correct to say that the Iraq War had a huge hand to play in the ability of Islamic State to expand across a fragile, war-ravaged Iraq. On this, most would agree that Iraq was a disastrous mistake, a war predicated on lies and executed poorly in terms of stabilisation and post-conflict reconstruction. However, we must not treat all potential interventions as equally amoral, ill-thought out bloodbaths peddled by megalomaniacal, testosterone-fuelled war mongers. We must not use historic mistakes as excuses to shirk future responsibility.
Then there are the claims made by people like Owen Jones who talk of “token” UK involvement that will achieve nothing of tactical importance and will only result in innocent deaths that bolster the recruiting power of Islamic State. There is compelling empirical evidence to counter this. Of the 200 strikes carried out by the RAF over the past year in Iraq, not a single civilian casualty has been reported. This ‘Dynamic Targeting’ which Britain’s Armed Forces are uniquely proficient in, is valuable both in terms of protecting innocent lives and maximising the damage to Islamic State. British involvement in striking IS in Syria is far from an insignificant step.
In reality, inaction in this case is much worse than simply shrugging off our duty to the international community. War has already been declared on this country, our allies and our way of life by the nutcases who make up the Islamic State. Should we then proceed to do very little about it?
As well as comprehending that the threat that Islamic State poses is genuine and existential, we must insist that our governments build comprehensive, overarching strategies to defeat the insane tyranny of fundamentalism that currently persists. The public must insist on meaningful and achievable objectives supported by all kinds of diplomatic and humanitarian means to bring about lasting stability and peace in the Levant. In terms of whether we should support the government’s proposals as they currently stand, there is a great deal to suggest that enormous lessons have been learnt. RUSI analysts have even gone so far as to say that “Cameron’s letter to the [Foreign Affairs Select] committee is lengthy, rigorous, and measured. It is not a dodgy dossier and there is little sign of sexed-up intelligence”. This said, however, the ability of Free Syrian Army and Kurdish Peshmerga troops to retake ISIS territory in the wake of airstrikes is a critical subject which must be elaborated on further by the Prime Minister.
If the civilised world is to overcome the barbarism of Islamic State and the underlying causes of its rise are to be successfully addressed, it must first be defeated on the battlefield. Political settlement in Syria, tackling the poisonous ideology of extremism and confronting Saudi Arabia’s double-game on Islamism cannot happen while IS remains in business.
However, there is equally no place for those like Tony Blair, for whom the deployment of troops came all too easily. Intervention, especially military-only, should not be a go-to policy in confronting the world’s problems. In fact, it is a very last resort, and one which must be executed with intelligence and properly formulated strategy front and centre.
War is an awful product of human existence that all sane people hope to see eradicated, but it is not brought to an end, and insidious foes like ISIS are not defeated by sanctimonious and unswerving pacifism-for-the-sake-of-it.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are not representative of Palatinate, and are those of the author only. If you disagree with the opinions expressed, or would like to write for Palatinate in response, please contact the Politics Section at politics@palatinate.org.uk.
Photograph: DVIDSHUB via Flickr
