‘Northern Powerhouse’: more than rhetoric?

By Oscar Rocklin

A city of great potential: night-time in Exchange Square, Manchester
A city of great potential: nighttime in Exchange Square, Manchester

“We must build a Northern Powerhouse”. This is the rhetoric that Chancellor George Osborne has been attempting to bludgeon into the public consciousness in the aftermath of the election. The stated aim of this new government is to build “a collection of northern cities – sufficiently close to each other that combined they can take on the world.” In other words, England’s northern cities are failing to live up to their economic potential, only increasing our national dependence on London. Rectifying this must now be a priority.

For several decades, one of the features of Britain’s economic life has been the perceived and real disparity between North and South. It seems that, by measures, from house prices, wages, employment, living standards, education and health that we have been living in Disraeli’s feared ‘Two Nations’. It is not merely that one region of the country is poorer than all others but that London has accelerated away from the rest of the country at breakneck pace. To many, it is a global city dragging the rest of Britain behind it.

In the wake of the financial crisis, this dependence on London and its finance sector has been revealed to be a huge weakness and one which rewards a precious few in the context of the whole country. The solution is one based not on squeezing London in order to equalise a divided nation, but instead to enhance the powers of local government and capabilities of industry in the North.

Does this attempt to rebalance the economic, social and political axes of Britain stack up? Aside from the fact that the nebulous term ‘North’ is more than a little hackneyed and vague, the ambition behind it seems well-founded. As a country, we have no second city or conurbation like Chicago or Frankfurt. However, the combined might of Liverpool, Manchester and Leeds as well as Sheffield, Hull and Newcastle, hold the potential to build a hub able to rival the economic behemoth that is London.

There are arguably already faint signs of this process coming to fruition. A devolution arrangement for Manchester has paved the way for other cities, and a new ‘Transport for North’ looks to follow TfL’s model that would better coordinate public transport at a regional level. It is clear that northern cities must not try and replicate London, but find niches in traditional areas of strength like advanced manufacturing and science.

The Sir Henry Royce Institute for Material Innovation in Manchester and the Advanced Manufacturing Research Centre of Sheffield show the way forward. Replicating the once billowing chimneys of Victorian industry with the white heat of science and technology appears to be at the fore of what the government is trying to achieve, and rightly so.

What of the North East? Much has been spoken of radical devolution and landmark new transport investment with regard to Manchester, Leeds, Liverpool and more recently Sheffield. Meanwhile, little or nothing of any consequence has been said of Newcastle, Sunderland or Middlesbrough. On top of this, the imminent end to steel production on Teesside does nothing but undermine the sense of progress or empowerment which politicians and civic leaders are seeking to nurture in the region.

If there is anything to be learnt from last year’s Scottish Independence referendum, it is that only so much indifference from central government will be accepted before whole segments of the country become totally disenfranchised. It is crucial that our politicians don’t make the same mistake by ignoring the needs of the North East for much longer.

The relative geographic seclusion of the North East is the major hurdle to overcome. The now restarted electrification of the TransPennine line is a tentative but important first step; however, much greater ambition is necessary. Trans-Atlantic flights from Newcastle Airport as recommended by Labour’s Infrastructure guru Lord Adonis would be an enormous show of faith. Furthermore, it is absolutely crucial that Universities are at the core of the endeavour. Giving students reasons not to jump on the first train to London once they’ve graduated must be at the forefront of the Northern Powerhouse.

In terms of providing the political infrastructure that the North East requires, following a one-size-fits-all approach that mimics what is happening in Manchester and elsewhere is not wise. When it comes to devolution, treating the North as one homogenous bloc that fails to recognise the differing requirements and wishes of its people would be a huge error. Most if not all of this depends on the government’s ability and willingness to put its money and political capital where its mouth is. This remains to be seen.

Students of this University are well aware of the beauty and history of this part of the world; it is high time that its cities were given the tools to recapture the dynamism that defined them as the birthplace of industry. Northern cities can and should be given the powers and infrastructure to flourish. For too long, it has seemed like Westminster has ignored anything outside of the M25. For once, outcomes must match up to rhetoric and the Northern Powerhouse, if it is to truly live up to its name, must empower the whole of Northern England.

Photograph: Phil Champion via Wikimedia Commons

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are not representative of Palatinate, and are those of the author only. If you disagree with the opinions expressed, please feel free to email the Politics section at politics@palatinate.org.uk.