The blurring of politics and comedy: A joke too far
Has anyone else noticed that something strange is happening to the state of our national politics? For the past few years it seems to many that the tone and nature of much of our national debate is  increasingly becoming an exercise in comedy and showmanship. Humour, wit and satire has always had an important role to play in British politics. For centuries comedians in one form or another, from 18th century caricaturist James Gillray to today’s panel of Have I Got News For You, have provided light relief and cutting insight into our politicians and political life. However, it now seems rather than using political events as material, comedians are now the ones attempting to make events themselves.
What on earth has brought this on? The modern sense of disaffection with once revered institutions and those in power, may go some way to explaining this. Much of the political capital wielded by figures like Russell Brand feeds off the utter contempt which much of the electorate have for the current crop of predictable, dreary and seemingly untrustworthy politicians. For many, names like Clegg, Cameron, Osborne, Miliband and Balls conjure up nothing but hateful thoughts. Party membership has hit record lows and tapping into this disillusionment and nihilistic despair makes for dependable satire but also exposes some important home truths regarding the disconnect between our political elite and the public at large. Celebrity comedians articulate our concerns and angers. They are even, on the surface at least, far more friendly and likeable people than our politicians. They seem to be on our side. Why shouldn’t we listen to them?
It is no wonder that more than ever people are taking note of our comedians as much as our politicians. Russell Brand’s rebranding as a campaigner, champion of the oppressed and man of the people is the most current example of this. It is also no surprise that in an attempt to stand out, some politicians have themselves picked up on the fact that they will be noticed if they play to the crowd and use comedy to their advantage.
The election of Boris Johnson to the London Mayoralty in 2008 is a landmark moment in this process. Rather than your typical public figure, Boris Johnson represents that new breed of pseudo-comic politicians who’s popularity is in part at least attributable to their outwardly affable, humorous ways. Much of his time during and follwing his first stint as a MP was spent playing for laughs by writing columns for the Telegraph and Spectator as well as appearing on popular TV shows, building what has become almost a cult of personality. Even today with talk of him as a potential future Prime Minister, he stills finds the time to fall into rivers or burble on about Classics with Paxman. However, this is not just a qwirk of his character; this is a man who knows how powerful a tool comedy is in today’s political world tainted by the cult of celebrity and image.
Whether this trend is set to continue into the future is unclear. Whether we want it to continue is a different matter. In the words of poet Christopher Fry “Comedy is an escape, not from truth but from despair”. With this in mind, we must remember that what comedians mostly do and are good at, is observing events and passing comment on them. Just because they can identify things that are wrong with the world which many of us already agree on, does not make figures like Brand fit to run or lead anything. Neither is it in anyone’s interests for those meant to represent us to go and forget that they are there to serve the public and not spend their time joking about and perfecting their image.
Watching Question Time starring Brand and Farage is a thoroughly depressing experience. Both exemplify the mantra that empty vessels do indeed make the most noise. They each embody lowest common denominator politics, which although light relief from Westminster drudgery, bring nothing but empty rhetoric. This was equally true of Farage’s bellicose row with Frankie Boyle on twitter over a comparison Boyle made between UKIP and the Nazis from which there is nothing at all to be gleaned of any value. Continuing to take politics less and less seriously is a dangerous prospect which threatens to undermine the quality of discussion on important issues, and if you’re being dramatic, the quality of our democracy as a whole. The best debate should often be funny, however we shouldn’t let the funnymen dictate it.
Photograph  from BBC.

