Vote of No Confidence in Grey College JCR President-elect passes by one vote
By Becks Fleet and Emily Doughty
Grey College JCR has voted in its recent JCR meeting to support a Vote of No Confidence in Ms Spillane, their JCR President-elect for the next academic year. The vote – which required a 2/3rds majority to pass – was passed by just a single vote.
The VONC motion, proposed by Jacob Cowley, accused Ms Spillane of “publicly complaining and crying over a then-potential FACSO (Financial and Community Support) Officer candidate, Asa Schuman” at an inter-exec formal at Hatfield College in January.
Ms Spillane was also accused of breaching impartiality rules by “gossiping to Grey students” about Mr Schuman in a “light-hearted manner”, which Mr Cowley stated could potentially “threaten the stability of an independent JCR”. Mr Schuman was later elected as Grey College JCR FACSO.
The VONC motion, proposed by Jacob Cowley, accused Ms Spillane of “publicly complaining and crying over a then-potential FACSO candidate, Asa Schuman”
Additionally, Ms Spillane was accused of breaching confidentiality rules as she “spoke openly of an on-going investigation involving Grey students”, including “naming some of those involved, even going as far to give her opinion on their character and the verdict of the investigation, which was yet to be made and is still ongoing” and that she was “heard saying that one of the people being investigated was in serious trouble, light-heartedly naming this ‘gossip’”.
In the Grey JCR meeting on Sunday 12th March, which saw a larger than usual turnout, Ms Spillane said that she had privately spoken to Mr Schuman about her concerns, and that they are friends. She also said that Mr Schuman told her that he was unaware that the VONC motion had been put forward, and that “he was a little confused and hurt, given that the nature of this motion raises the question of his character and suitability for the role”.
She also stated that she believes she didn’t breach impartiality rules as she had not signed the code of conduct at the time of the accused breach, and that she was ill at home during the vast majority of Mr Schuman’s FACSO campaign.
Ms Spillane was accused of breaching confidentiality rules as she “spoke openly of an on-going investigation involving Grey students”
Finally, Ms Spillane claims that she did not speak openly about an ongoing investigation, but was instead commenting on the two individuals involved in the investigation in regard to a different incident involving her boyfriend. She claimed that “I feel I was within my rights to speak harshly against them on a subject completely unrelated to the investigation”.
The Vote of No Confidence, which took place in person and required a 2/3rds majority to pass, saw 141 votes in favour out of a total 210 valid votes, just a single vote above the required 2/3rds majority of 140 votes, meaning Ms Spillane was removed from her role as President-elect effective immediately.
In a statement to Palatinate, Ms Spillane said: “This whole process has felt unfair from start to finish.
“In the case of the first two accusations, there was categorically no breaking of either constitutional rules or code of conduct, a point which was clarified by the Grey Chair of Trustees. The third and final accusation was based on an anonymous statement which had no concrete details of what was actually said.
“In the case of the first two accusations, there was categorically no breaking of either constitutional rules or code of conduct, a point which was clarified by the Grey Chair of Trustees”
Ms Spillane
“The lack of opportunity to defend myself until the actual JCR meeting, to supposedly allow members to “scrutinise the motion without influence”, went against any standard process of innocent-until-proven-guilty.
“The JCR meeting turned into a popularity contest, with more people turning out to the meeting than voted in my initial hust for president. After the motion was concluded, the meeting barely met quorum on the remaining motions as the majority of attending members left immediately after the Vote of No Confidence was concluded, passing by only one vote.
“The process has tarnished my experience of Grey College and my respect for the JCR. After dedicating two years of my time at Durham to the Grey Welfare team, one of those as a senior welfare officer and an exec member, this has been a very challenging experience for me.
“The process has tarnished my experience of Grey College and my respect for the JCR”
ms Spillane
“However, I wish the Grey JCR all the best in the coming year, with or without a new JCR president.”
When asked for comment on the situation, a Grey College JCR spokesperson said: “The JCR will hold an emergency general meeting including a Presidential Election.
“If no-one is elected, or if no candidates stand, the Trust will hire someone to undertake the administrative part of the role, with other functions being shared between the rest of the executive.”
Image: DS Pugh via Wikimedia Commons

