Visitors report “pure carnage” at Lumiere opening night
By Jasmine Davey
Lumiere has been criticised by visitors who have described the festival’s opening night as “pure carnage”. The light show, which featured 29 instillations across Durham City and Shildon, attracted over 120,000 visitors. However, the event has been criticised by attendees who complained that its poor organisation made it a “horrible experience”.
A video posted on TikTok show security inside Durham Cathedral physically restraining a man who was attempting to re-join his girlfriend in the crowd, whilst a woman shouts “you’re making my son cry, stop it”. The dispute was in response to visitors not being permitted to visit the Cathedral toilets without exiting the exhibition, and not being allowed re-entry. The caption of the video stated “stunning festival, shockingly poor logistics”.
Comments on the video recalled similar experiences. “[The opening night] was a truly awful evening”, one user stated. “Extreme overcrowding, most exhibitions were closed. Vile staff. Good riddance to Lumiere!”
Responding to this incident, Artichoke (who organise the Lumiere festival) stated “for the safety of visitors, which is our utmost priority, and to ensure there were clear entry and exit points, there was a no re-entry policy in place for the Lumiere installation in the Cathedral Cloister which was clearly communicated throughout. The member of staff in question was following safety protocol as briefed. Following a review of the incident, staff were rebriefed. We apologise for any distress caused.”

Visitors also expressed anger as to the difficulty of entering the cathedral, recalling staff cutting off entry to the building at 8pm whilst there was ‘gridlock’ on Palace Green, before re-opening the entrance later in the evening. This “brief pause” was due to wet floor in the cathedral entrance way, which, as stated by Artichoke, needed to be “mopped and dried for safety reasons”.
Speaking to Palatinate, festival attendees complained about the disorganisation of the event. “I’d travelled up from London to attend Lumiere, I was really excited”, one visitor said. “The security felt quite bizarre and the overcrowding was just unacceptable and basically marred the whole experience.
“It felt like nothing was really accessible apart from the cathedral in the ticketed zone, which had the most unorganised queue I’ve seen and security was just blocking it off anyways. All that for some pretty uninspiring light exhibitions which were nice but not really memorable.”
The festival also took place amidst poor weather conditions, forcing organisers to close 6 of the 29 artworks on Thursday 13th November. This was due to the river flooding, making part of the ticketed route inaccessible. Some attendees have attributed the disorganisation of opening night to the conditions; the bulk of the one-way system is located along the river, from Prebends Bridge to Framwellgate Bridge. Because this pathway was inaccessible, visitors were advised to walk along a residential street parallel to the river.
Speaking to Palatinate, Artichoke emphasised “audience safety is our absolute priority. Planning for Lumiere takes place over many months prior to the event with a highly experienced Audience Management and Event team and the involvement of all statutory bodies and emergency services. Detailed event and audience management plans are developed which include audience capacity, route planning and staff training, and these are signed off at the highest level by the Safety Planning Group which includes representatives from each of the emergency services and key agencies.
On Thursday 13 November, the weather and rising river levels necessitated the closure of some pieces and a dynamic response to managing visitors. This led to us implementing our pre- planned contingencies which required the redeployment and rebriefing of some of our Lumiere staff to keep our audience safe.”

Previous to concerns over the festival’s logistics, Lumiere has also become a point of political debate following the announcement that the 2025 show will be its last. Reform-led Durham County Council came under fire in the House of Commons during Prime Minister’s Questions on October 22nd, after Labour MP Alan Strickland argued that the council’s decision to “axe” the festival “undermined businesses and communities”. However, it later emerged that the decision was made in January 2025, when the council was controlled by the Liberal Democrats.
The current council has made assurances that it will attempt to continue some form of light show in Durham. Speaking to GB News, council leader Andrew Husband stated “I would like to reaffirm that should a sustainable funding strategy be found for Lumiere, we would be supportive of a refreshed and revitalised event continuing in the County”.
Cllr Husband later came into conflict with Labour North East Mayor Kim McGuinness after she wrote the councillor a letter expressing her shock that the event was not being backed. “I am disappointed that your team did not consult my office prior to the announcement”, McGuinness wrote on 13th November.
“My hope now is that we can work together to reserve this cut and keep major events at the heart of Durham. I would be happy to discuss this further in person.”
In response, Cllr Husband stated “the Mayor has acknowledged this situation could have been handled better. However, public responses to private, well intentioned and constructive dialogue, particularly on the opening day of Lumiere, are damaging and amount to nothing more than a cheap political stunt, and not in the spirit of what I understand the combined authority to represent.
It was disappointing to receive such an unhelpful public response to my private letter to Mayor McGuinness where I clarified the factual position regarding Lumiere in Durham, and to see the points I have addressed in public and private statements continue to be misrepresented by the Mayor.”
Beyond the disputes surrounding the festival, visitors still expressed praise for Lumiere’s artwork. Ellen, a local resident who has lived in Durham for over a decade, told Palatinate that she was particularly impressed by the ‘Solace’ and ‘Everyone Ever’ artworks inside the cathedral, dubbing them “very impressive and effective”.

Palace Green’s ‘Elysium Garden’ was also identified as a highlight of the festival. Inspired by the mythical afterlife gardens of Elysium, the “supersized forest of giant illuminated flowers” was originally commissioned to celebrate the life of Anita Roddick, founder of Bodyshop. However, the installation has grown over the past 20 years, with new flowers being added each season.

Despite the difficulties encountered by many visitors, Lumiere still attracted tens of thousands of visitors, cementing its reputation as one of the region’s most significant cultural events. As discussions continue over its future, both supporters and critics agree that the festival holds a unique place in the city’s identity.
Image credits: Jasmine Davey

