From contraception to cotes: the Great Pigeon War of Norwich Market

By Jasmine Davey

Any visitors to Norwich market will be familiar with the scraggy grey birds that infest the square in an endless mission to procure a greasy chip. These bedraggled creatures are a frequent topic of contention amongst local residents; critics have called for their removal, stating that they pose a risk to Market vendors and visitors. However, pigeon enthusiasts have retaliated by distributing ‘industrial’ levels of food across the Market in an attempt to further encourage the birds. 

The dispute first began when Norwich City Council (NCC) spent £4,000 on employing a hawk to discourage pigeons from nesting in the area. Falconry has grown increasingly popular over the past decade, with birds of prey being deployed across areas such as the Scottish Parliament building, the British Library, and London train stations, to fend off the birds. However, pigeon fans have labelled the tactic as ‘cruel’, arguing that they are equally entitled to the space as humans. 

Typically painted as a ‘political’ debate by the media, the issues surrounding Norwich Market’s pigeons is inherently scientific. Methods of pigeon control are wide ranging, with options including culling, egg swapping, and contraception. Creative as they are, the efficiency of these methods is contested. Just how well does pigeon birth control actually work?

Researchers at the University of York have been instrumental in the application of contraception for ‘invasive’ wildlife species, which is a “more publicly acceptable” means of controlling population numbers. Research has demonstrated that contraception can limit the growth of pigeon communities by over half; a 2022 study in Barcelona found that the nicarbazin drug, which was contained within their food, reduced flocks by 55% over two years. Another trial in Brussels has seen pigeon numbers drop by 50%

Limiting reproduction rates is essential to the control of pigeon populations. Pigeons can procreate up to eight times per year, with just five pigeon pairings being capable of reproducing 400 pigeons within two years. However, critics such as Nadia Xenakis, who led a pilot program in Vancouver, have highlighted that stalling reproduction rates merely prevents populations from growing, rather than reducing them. 

The efficiency of pest contraception does depend on environmental factors. For instance, pigeon reproduction rates are directly correlated to food supply. With roughly 30 food vendors, and pigeon enthusiasts that distribute kilos of bird seed across the area, the Norwich Market pigeons do not exactly go hungry; this means that they procreate at a much greater frequency than pigeons starving in a train station, for instance. A 2021 Bucknall University study demonstrated that food availability notably increases the reproductive rate of feral pigeons in towns and cities. Therefore, whilst contraception may not be an effective option in areas where food supply is low, it would have a greater impact in areas such as Norwich Market. 

A petition calling for the implementation of a dovecote beside Norwich Market has gained over 4,000 signatures, although the Council has not demonstrated any enthusiasm for the idea.

NCC has dismissed the contraceptive method as a solution to its pigeon dilemma due to it not being licenced in the UK. Concerns have also been raised about the potential negative consequences of the method. If it were to be introduced, the contraceptive would be laced within regulated feeds provided to the birds by the council. However, critics have pointed out that there is no way of restricting the laced food to pigeon consumption, meaning other (potentially endangered) species could consume the drug. There is also a concern that other species would consume the drug if they preyed on the pigeons, or that pigeon waste would contain levels of hormones dangerous to the environment and surrounding humans.

Pigeon enthusiasts have also proposed dovecotes as a means of controlling population growth. Dovecotes, which first emerged in the Middle East over 4,000 years ago, allow human moderators to switch out live pigeon eggs for fake eggs. This enables the control of population growth and does not cause any distress to the birds. A petition calling for the implementation of a dovecote beside Norwich Market has gained over 4,000 signatures, although the Council has not demonstrated any enthusiasm for the idea. 

Culling is typically seen as an inhumane form of pigeon control. Manchester Victoria Station is currently facing backlash after it undertook a mass pigeon cull. Northern Rail stated this was due to the birds “posing a risk” to staff and customers. Volunteer group ‘Manchester Pigeon Rehab’ have investigated the issue, and reported their findings to the police. Recent research has also deemed culling inefficient; if half a pigeon flock is killed, the population can recover to its original size within merely a few weeks.

Although a solution for the infamous Norwich Market pigeons has not yet been agreed upon, an abundance of scientifically proven methods of human pigeon control remain. Whether it be a dovecote, hormones, or feeding fines, the small grey creatures of Norwich Market have a long way to go.  

Image credit: Jasmine Davey