Billy B plugs revisited: almost a quarter of seats found lacking

By Hugh Ludford and Jasmine Davey

Many of our returning readers will remember our audit of the Billy B’s plug sockets back in May, in which we tested every single plug in the library. Yes, you heard that right. Every. Single. Plug. 1,832 of them.

Our report then focused on the likelihood of any plug on a given floor not working: we found that while only 2% of plugs on Level 4 were broken, that figure rose to 20% broken on level 2, and 42% non-functional in the café.

In the aftermath of our groundbreaking first report, though, we recognised that this data didn’t tell the whole story.

“We…found several study spots with no plug sockets at all,” read our May article, “If we had included those in our count, the proportion of study spaces with guaranteed access to a plug would be significantly lower”.

We at Palatinate knew that a second audit was needed, measuring not only which plugs worked, but which seats had access to a working plug. And so, during the summer holidays, our roving data collector Jasmine returned to the Billy B for a new study.

Our new method relied on collecting two numbers for each floor: the number of seats with access to a working plug socket, and the number without access working plug socket.

We defined “accessible” plugs as those within length of a standard laptop cable, since this is what the sockets are most frequently used for. Additionally, we only counted individual seats at a desk, excluding bookable study rooms, private rooms like the Kepier postgrad room, and seats that already have a desktop computer. Therefore, the total number of seats counted in this study was 1,334.

This would give a more accurate figure, since we had observed in our initial investigation a number of desks with more plugs than seats – one table which seated four and had eight working plugs, for example – as well as a number of desks with no sockets at all.

With this established, the floor-by-floor results are as follows:

Level four is still the best floor, with 86.3% of seats having a working plug sockets. At least a fifth of the seats on the other levels do not have plug socket access: 20.3% of level three seats do not have a plug, a figure that rises to 29% on Level 1.

Level two is by far the worst-performing floor. Here, 42% of seats have no working socket: a figure much more stark than the 20% of non-working plugs we found there in our first survey. This suggests a high level of “clustering” – where some seats have access to many plugs, but many seats do not have access to even one.

Across the whole library, almost a quarter of the seats we measured did not have access to a working plug socket. 23.6% of seats across the main levels had no access. This figure would likely be higher if the café were included in our audit, based on our previous investigation where only 58 of the 100 sockets there were functional.

The figure of 23.6% of seats lacking electricity access should better reflect the boots-on-the ground experience of students using the library. In our previous report we found that 13.7% of plug sockets were broken, but the larger proportion of seats lacking plugs points to problems not just with the reliability of plugs, but with their distribution throughout the library.

In response to these findings, a Durham University spokesperson reiterated word-for-word the University’s comments on our previous plugs audit:

“If you find a plug socket not working, please report it to the Help and Information Desk, by email to: library@durham.ac.uk, or via the live chat, including the study space number.

“Our study space booking system indicates which spaces have a power socket. If you cannot access a power socket, you can borrow a charged laptop for use in the Library. Spare chargers are also available at the Help and Information Desk.”

We hope that this investigation will help to inform your seat choice next time you find yourself in the Billy B. May the odds be ever in your favour!

Cover Image: Thomas Tomlinson, Palatinate