Venues must learn from O2 Brixton Academy tragedy

By Johnny Luker

As someone who saw their first gig in the 02 Brixton Academy and lives there locally, I was deeply shocked to see a crowd crush as such a historic venue. Loss-of-life should never be a remote possibility at music events. However, overselling and understaffing at the Asake show led to the deaths of Rebecca Ikumelo, 33, and security guard Gaby Hutchinson, 23. Wale Ikumel, brother of Rebecca, has called for “all of the justice that can be given on her behalf because she deserves it.” But we must ask, why is justice necessary?

Some have blamed over-eager individuals who forced their way into a side entrance and videos have even surfaced online of crowds shoving past security and police into the front doors. In videos posted on social media, crowds are seen surging forward and police pushing back, with one woman being shoved down the stairs. The police look overwhelmed and aggressive, but the crowd are undeniably breaking the entry rules of the venue.

Loss of life should never be a remote possibility at music events

These rules, however, were breached by the hired security company ‘AP Security’ first, with one anonymous guard suggesting that bribes were taken. The whistle- blower told the BBC that “some staff made £1,000 cash” by charging individuals without tickets straight in. It is difficult to blame the crowd of legitimate ticket holders when this sort of corruption is taking place whilst they are being refused entry.

The word ‘crush’ brings to mind the nightmarish events of Travis Scott’s ‘Astroworld’ festival in 2021 where 10 people died and 25 were hospitalized. Astroworld received criticism for a poor guests to staff ratio, something that the Brixton 02 whistle-blower has also reported.

According to a document by the BBC, Brixton Academy reportedly needs 200+ security staff for Afrobeats and Dancehall events classified as risk tier-5 like Asake, presumably due to the majority of fans being teenagers. Only 110 security staff were present on the night. Telling young people to behave in these situations is clearly fruitless as Asake warned his fans on Twitter before the show, saying “Please do not come to Brixton Academy if you do not have a valid ticket”. Venues have a responsibility to hire enough security staff to protect fans.

Anyone who has seen the horrific Woodstock ’99 documentary on Netflix will be familiar with the thin line between excitement and out-and-out carnage. Idyllic scenes of hippy-ish community reminiscent of the 70’s Woodstock festivals quickly fade into violence and flames. Does this deterioration suggest the younger generation is getting more and more rowdy?

But it’s not only young people at gigs. The final of the Euros football competition in Wembley saw spectators breaking through barriers and past security staff in order to steal a seat. English football fans are notorious for their hooliganism and this event only worsened their image in the global football world. Passion is something shared by music lovers and football fans, but when the herd mentality kicks in, security must be equipped with crowd management techniques will keep fans safe.

Event runners like the Academy clearly haven’t learnt from this and have allowed outsourced security let the historic venue get overrun. The rise of the gig-economy means that private security in venues like the Brixton Academy have less incentive to refuse bribes and to put themselves in the way of pushy concert-goers.

Venues have a responsibility to hire enough security staff to protect fans

Durham club-goers will be familiar with the burning desire to get into venues. There have often been rumours about a backdoor entrance to Jimmys and speculation that a homemade stamp with a permanent marker can gain you access to certain clubs via the smoking area.

But the Durham club-goer, familiar with minor overselling and crowded venues cannot, in reality, compare their experience to the trauma of Astroworld or Brixton Academy. No doubt there are many students who will be travelling to Newcastle in the coming terms concerned about the crush in Brixton. Hopefully the event will mark a change in event management.

The owners of Brixton Academy said in a statement that, “Academy Music Group is committed to understanding what happened and cooperating with the various investigations that are under way, including providing full cooperation to the police”. More must be done by venue owners than hiring ineffective security companies. The tragedy in Brixton must not spell the end of the Academy.

Image credit: Samuel Regan-Asante via Unsplash