Elon-gate: the free speech debate
By Johnny Luker
“The bird is freed” announced the wealthiest man in the world on Friday as Twitter withdrew from trading on the New York Stock Exchange. Since the beginning of the year, Elon Musk has been in antagonistic negotiations with the previous owners of the social media platform involving vast sums of money and the threat of court.
In January Musk began aggressively buying Twitter shares and became the majority stakeholder at 9% without filing the necessary SEC paperwork (the US Securities and Exchange Commission is tasked with preventing market manipulation). When Musk finally revealed his investment in an SEC filing on April 4, Twitter shares rose the largest amount since their IPO in 2013. One can’t help but be reminded of Musk’s manipulation of Tesla’s share price in 2020 when he casually tweeted that the price of Tesla stock was “too high imo”.
There is also his track record with Bitcoin. Tweeting that Tesla had bought $1.5b worth of crypto in 2021, the billionaire caused a surge in the environmentally unsound cryptocurrency’s price. “The volatility we have seen [in Bitcoin] is an unexpected function of what I would call market manipulation by Elon Musk,” commented Magda Wierzycka, the CEO of financial services firm Sygnia, “…if that happened to a listed company he would be investigated and severely sanctioned by the SEC”. Hopefully, the SEC will be quicker on Musk’s case now that he owns and controls the platform which he has so often used to generate huge sums of money in market-shaking ‘pump-and-dump schemes’.
There is also the main issue on the minds of Twitter’s 230 million users: free speech. An example of the free speech Musk (a self-proclaimed “free speech absolutist”) will make possible is already being seen. The Observer recently reported that the far-right group Britain First have re-joined the social network after having been banned in 2017 for posting “anti-Muslim videos”. The group celebrated with a post on the messenger app Telegram saying that their recent Twitter posts would “usually be suspended immediately”.
Twitter has long been a space that contributes to political polarisation but Musk’s announcement of different streams for different users could make it easier for far-right groups like Britain First to openly propagate racist media. He suggested in a recent tweet that “being able to select which version of Twitter you want is probably better, much as it would be for a movie maturity rating. The rating of the tweet itself could be self-selected, then modified by user feedback”.
Though this sounds like a positive censorship feature, in practice it will create an opt-in top, or ‘mature’, the tier in which extreme views can circulate and be perpetuated. If Twitter was a traditional media form like a newspaper, for example, this would be its announcement of a new, exclusive far-right magazine.
Role is not to be bound by the First Amendment, but our role is to serve a healthy public
conversation… and to focus less on free speech, but thinking about how the times have changes
One may ask whether Twitter even needs to fulfil this requirement for free speech. Previous Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal, fired immediately by Musk, had suggested that the site’s “role is not to be bound by the First Amendment, but our role is to serve a healthy public conversation… and to focus less on free speech, but thinking about how the times have changed”.
Agrawal was well within his rights to suggest this. The first amendment only applies to state actors – there is a common misconception that it prohibits anyone from limiting free speech, especially private entities like Twitter. The Supreme Court has also determined that the protection of speech is not absolute.
Perhaps in a world where misinformation and extreme views are so accessible to children, the priority should be ‘healthy public conversation’? Rapper Ye, formerly Kanye West, returned to Twitter after the buyout, having been banned for posting Anti-Semitic conspiracy theories. Considering many, if not the majority, of Ye’s fans and followers are young people who idolise him, doesn’t Twitter have a responsibility to shield them from racist outbursts?
[Musk] is aligning the platform with his own personality, trivialising a space which so often needs to be taken seriously
Whether Musk is treating this takeover as seriously as the rest of the world remains to be seen. He announced his entrance into Twitter HQ with a ‘Let that sink in’ meme depicting himself carrying a sink into the offices. Is the largest global forum for debate being taken over by a practical joker? Self-titled as such in his new Twitter bio, ’Chief Twit’, he is aligning the platform with his own personality, trivialising a space which so often needs to be taken seriously.
Photograph credits: Duncan Cumming

