Saving Big Dog – the Boris Johnson comeback being planned in plain sight
By Alex Everest House
The last words uttered at the despatch box by Boris Johnson during his final Prime Minister’s Questions were widely interpreted as a hint that he would eventually walk through the famous black door of 10 Downing Street once more: “Hasta la vista, baby”. The road, however, is bumpy. Two separate inquiries over two separate issues may well see his career finished off, there is deep resentment towards him from much of his core parliamentary base, and to top it all off, ITV’s new podcast series has some explosive new revelations about ‘partygate’ in the words of the sources that helped bring the former Prime Minister down.
Two separate inquiries over two separate issues may well see his career finished off
Yet, allies close to him seem to believe, all is not lost. The team behind ‘Operation Save Big Dog’ – ministers that served in his cabinets like Nigel Adams, political strategist Ross Kempsall and special advisor Charlotte Owen – believe support for Rishi Sunak will eventually wear thin. Perhaps they are right about support for the current government, with Labour now regularly more than 20 points ahead in polls, but their answer is not likely to go down well either. The ailment that the Conservative party faces is a fundamental split – is saving Big Dog really the remedy?
Boris Johnson may no longer be in office in Number 10, but his political future only continues to grow more uncertain. A new podcast series from ITV News, Partygate: The Inside Story, has only added fuel to the fire; civil servant sources have only confirmed that the culture inside Whitehall stemmed from the very top: Johnson was supposedly heard at an event during lockdown declaring “this is the most unsocially distanced party in the UK right now”. Further suggestions that “multiple couples were getting it on”, with some even having sex in plain view of other guests at another event is only more insufferable news for the people who had loved ones die on the days that Downing Street partied the nights away. Numerous polls had Johnson’s net approval rating close to -50 at the time of his departure, and to many within the parliamentary Conservative party it is hard to see how that can possibly improve. Indeed, the British electorate can be very tolerant to scandal, yet history suggests hypocrisy and lies are extremely hard to earn forgiveness for.
Indeed, the British electorate can be very tolerant to scandal, yet history suggests hypocrisy and lies are extremely hard to earn forgiveness for.
Of course, that is not the only barrier to re-entry that Johnson has. The Commons Privileges Committee will this year determine whether the former Prime Minister deliberately misled the House with his denials of parties and events in Whitehall. If they do indeed find that helied to Parliament, a suspension of more than 10 days from the Commons would likely trigger a by-election under the Recall of MPs Act – something he is not certain to win in his current seat.
Additionally, the separate coronavirus inquiry will begin in the spring to scrutinise the government’s response to the pandemic, particularly in the early days. Many believe it will be embarrassing for Johnson, with former special advisor Dominic Cummings likely to seek revenge for his ousting from the top team in November 2020. With phrases such as “let the bodies pile high in their thousands” ready to re-enter the public domain, it is difficult not to see any kind attempt by the Big Dog team to reinstate their man as leader marred.
Perhaps the greatest difficulty, however, comes in that the public will not decide whether Sunak takes the Conservatives into the next election – Tory MPs will. After a tumultuous half-decade which has seen four different Prime Ministers, the desperate struggle for calm on the backbenches is felt intensely by many who sit on them. To cause a further rift by imposing someone as controversial as Johnson would be a suicidal move to many; Sunak noted that the Conservative party must “unite or die” during an inaugural speech as Prime Minister.
Yet, the Conservative party is already split: with MPs like former Culture Secretary Nadine Dorries openly attacking Sunak on Twitter and polls of party members consistently showing he is less popular than Johnson, the two sides in the coalition are deeply sceptical of each other. With the party in such a fractious state, it will take very little for MPs to begin undermining their confidence in the government, and that only spells trouble for Sunak.
The local elections in May could well be such a turning point; with Labour so far ahead in polls, numerous councils in traditionally safe areas could be lost, only driving up resentment against Sunak amongst the grassroots. Perhaps it is no surprise then that allies of Johnson have been briefing the papers on leadership challenges: The Times reported that a challenge was being considered for after the local elections, but that it could be avoided by moving Johnson to an even safer seat for the next general election. It was, of course, shot down very quickly by a spokesperson, but it speaks volumes of the tactics that the Big Dog team will use.
The local elections in May could well be such a turning point
So what about after the 2024 election? With Sunak currently trailing far behind Labour, and with very few experts predicting a positive economic outlook for the year ahead, many backbench MPs on the government side have already privately concluded that loss is inevitable.
Indeed, we have just witnessed a wave of Tory MPs announce that they will not be standing again next year. As a result, it is not hard to imagine them looking towards who they see as a ‘proven winner’ – some have even declared this publicly already. The very fact that Johnson managed to garner 102 nominations in the autumn party leadership contest is testament to the fact that significant parliamentary support remains even if public support has waned. If Sunak’s electoral prospects remain as dire as they are currently, there is little doubt that Johnson’s allies will be reading the room well in advance – perhaps a party leadership contest will have started in all but name before the election is even over. Will Boris Johnson be Prime Minister again one day? It is an uphill battle: he must avoid being found to have misled parliament, must avoid being implicated in the coronavirus inquiry, and must not be a disruption in Parliament. Even if luck is on his side, the public are clear in their perception – they do not want him back. Those who are more pragmatic have realised that, but the Conservative party is just as ideological as it is pragmatic. Saving Big Dog has already failed once; trying to do it again might simply be flogging a dead horse.
Image: Prime Minister’s Office via Wikimedia Commons

