Using charity as a press opportunity: Sportspeople are going too far

By Avesta Afshari-Mehr

When we think of elite athletes, one of the many images that come to mind are photos of them posing next to vulnerable people in their branded sport tracksuits. The latest example saw England Rugby players visiting the Windsor Homeless Project, accompanied by a polished LinkedIn caption declaring they were “Proud to give back.”  

Philanthropy once implied anonymity, or at least modesty

The phrase itself is quite revealing. Not “we’re glad to help out,” but ‘proud’ – most crucially, proud enough to ensure the world sees it. This leads into an uncomfortable truth about the usage of charity in modern sport. It is increasingly becoming content and being used as a press opportunity.  

There was a time, some years ago, when philanthropy implied anonymity, or at least modesty. Giving was understood as a moral obligation, not a branding exercise. Today, charitable acts are routinely packaged into public relations campaigns, complete with professional photography, coordinated messaging, and social media amplification. The charitable act itself becomes secondary to its visibility. 

I’m not trying to argue that such visits are of no value. For the organisations involved, attention can translate into donations, volunteers, and most importantly public awareness. But framing matters. When charity becomes a spectacle, it shifts from sacrifice to virtue signaling. 

Yes, elite athletes and sporting organisations now operate as global brands. Their public image is a financial asset. Acts of charity help cultivate that image by humanising figures whose immense wealth might otherwise provoke resentment. A carefully staged visit to a homeless shelter softens the harsher optics of those multimillion-pound contracts. 

This contradiction lies at the heart of the issue. Professional sport is defined by extraordinary financial inequality. The average player in leagues such as the Premier League or the NBA earns sums that vastly exceed what most people will accumulate in a lifetime. A single week’s wages for some athletes could fund housing, education, or healthcare for hundreds. Yet systemic giving on that scale never happens. Instead, charity tends to appear in carefully curated moments including team visits, foundation launches, symbolic gestures, all posted across Instagram, TikTok, the works. These acts are meaningful in isolation, but negligible in proportion to the wealth involved. The uncomfortable question arises: if sport genuinely prioritised social responsibility, why does its economic structure remain so untouched? 

There are, of course, exceptions. Individuals such as Marcus Rashford have used their platform to advocate for structural change

So join me in imagining, for a moment, a different model. If even a modest percentage of elite athletes’ salaries were quietly redistributed: not through public campaigns, but rather through sustained, structural giving, the impact on poverty would be measurable. Considerably more measurable than that of whatever could be gained from the current mode of press opportunities. Entire communities could be transformed. Homelessness could be substantially reduced. Educational access could expand dramatically. Isn’t that what they ultimately want? 

There are, of course, exceptions. Individuals such as Marcus Rashford have used their platform to advocate for structural change, campaigning publicly on child food poverty. Others, like Cristiano Ronaldo, have reportedly made significant private donations. Yet even these examples illustrate the broader dynamic: what becomes public is what shapes perception, and perception is valuable. And the deeper fundamental issue is cultural. Modern sport exists within an ecosystem of media coverage, sponsorship, and prestigious branding. Visibility = currency. Every public act contributes to the narrative surrounding an athlete or organisation. Charity, in this context, becomes part of that narrative architecture. But this inevitably raises an uncomfortable ethical distinction between charity and altruism. Charity performed publicly generates two beneficiaries: the recipient and the giver’s reputation. Charity performed privately benefits only the recipient. And true generosity simply does not need an audience.  

I reiterate: I am not making an argument against athletes supporting charitable causes. Au contraire, their resources and influence give them extraordinary capacity to help. But the public, and the media, must be more discerning in how such acts are interpreted. Not every photographed visit is an act of selfless philanthropy. Sometimes, it is simply ‘good public relations’. Sport loves and hails the language of integrity; celebrates authenticity and humility and character. Yet those values are most visible not in the gestures we see, but in the ones we do not. 

Image by Yunus Erdogdu via Pexels