Myanmar military proxy expected to win sham elections

By Avesta Afshari-Mehr

Myanmar’s military-backed Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) has claimed victory in what it describes as the country’s first successful national election since the armed forces seized power in a 2021 coup. The vote, which was held amidst an ongoing civil war and widespread repression, has been rejected by much of the international community as neither free, nor fair; and is widely viewed as an attempt by the junta to legitimise continued military rule under the façade of supposed ‘electoral politics’.

According to the military authorities, the USDP secured a dominant share of the contested seats in both houses of parliament. Even without a landslide, the outcome was effectively predetermined. Under Myanmar’s constitution, drafted during a previous period of military rule, 25% of parliamentary seats are automatically reserved for serving military officers, granting the armed forces an in-built veto over constitutional change and decisive influence over government formation. Major opposition parties (most notably the National League for Democracy (NLD) which won a landslide in the last genuinely competitive election in 2020), were dissolved or barred from participating. Voting did not take place in large swathes of the country affected by armed resistance or ethnic conflict, further undermining the credibility of the process.

”Major opposition parties (most notably the National League for Democracy (NLD) which won a landslide in the last genuinely competitive election in 2020), were dissolved or barred from participating”

General Min Aung Hlaing, the military chief who led the coup and now serves as the country’s de facto ruler under a variety of different titles (Senior General; Prime Minister; Chairman), has dismissed international criticism of the election. “We are not concerned whether this is recognised by foreign countries or not,” he has said. “We recognise the people’s vote. It should be like that.” For critics, however, the exclusion of opposition voices; pervasive climate of fear; the ongoing imprisonment of political activists…. make all such claims ring hollow.

For the people of Myanmar, the election is unlikely to bring stability or relief. Since the coup, the country has been plunged into a brutal conflict between the military and a patchwork of resistance groups, including the parallel National Unity Government (NUG) and ethnic armed organisations. Millions have been displaced; economy contracted sharply; human rights groups have documented widespread abuses, including air strikes on civilian areas as well as mass detentions. Rather than opening a path towards reconciliation, the election risks entrenching military dominance and prolonging the conflict by closing off meaningful political avenues for dissent.

International reaction has been largely condemnatory. Western governments, including the United States, the United Kingdom and members of the European Union, have rejected the legitimacy of the vote and reiterated that any political process excluding major democratic forces cannot reflect the will of the Myanmar people. The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), of which Myanmar is a member, has also declined to recognise the election, maintaining its position that progress towards peace requires inclusive dialogue rather than unilateral action by the junta.

”The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), of which Myanmar is a member, has also declined to recognise the election”

Punitive measures available to the international community are limited but most definitely not insignificant. Targeted sanctions against senior military figures and military-linked businesses could be expanded, thereby further restricting the junta’s access to foreign currency and arms. Governments may also refuse diplomatic recognition to officials appointed through the new parliament; limit Myanmar’s participation in international forums; and also strengthen existing arms embargoes. Human rights groups have called for greater coordination to close loopholes that allow the military to finance its operations through natural resources and cross-border trade.

As for endorsement, few countries have openly supported the election outcome. China and Russia have maintained pragmatic relations with the military authorities, emphasising stability and non-interference to be of utmost importance, and have continued diplomatic engagement without explicitly validating the vote. Neighbouring countries such as India have taken a cautious approach, balancing strategic interests with unease over the junta’s actions. No major power, however, has declared the election free and fair.

Rather than marking a return to democratic governance, Myanmar’s election appears to have formalised a political reality already shaped by force. For many inside the country, it is less a turning point than a confirmation that the struggle over Myanmar’s future remains unresolved.

Image: Vadim Savitsky via Wikimedia Commons