Who pays the real price for our clothes?
By Avesta Afshari-Mehr
A certain relative of mine has a rather impressive talent for finding clothes that cost almost nothing.
Give her a few minutes on Shein and she can emerge with an entire elaborate wardrobe for less than the price of a decent dinner. A dress here; a pashmina there; perhaps a pair of corduroys that cost less than a taxi home. She loves the variety, the convenience and, above all, the price. What she does not love is thinking about how any of it is possible. Nor does she not like it when I try to show her how it is.
Perhaps that is the most uncomfortable thing about modern fashion: how successfully we have separated the clothes we buy from the people who make them.
Perhaps that is the most uncomfortable thing about modern fashion: how successfully we have separated the clothes we buy from the people who make them
Shein has become almost synonymous with ultra-fast fashion, producing enormous quantities of inexpensive clothing at extraordinary speed. Yet investigations into its supply chain have painted a very different picture from the glossy world with endless scrolling presented to consumers. A 2024 investigation by Swiss NGO Public Eye found workers at Shein suppliers in Guangzhou still reporting 12-hour days, six or seven days a week… around 75 hours a week.
Now that £5 top suddenly looks rather different.
It is tempting to regard this as a problem belonging to ‘fast fashion’, safely contained within the world of online shopping apps and disposable trends; but that would allow the rest of the fashion industry to escape scrutiny.
And even luxury fashion has proved capable of hiding exploitation behind a much more glamorous façade. In 2024, Italian prosecutors placed a Dior manufacturing subsidiary under judicial administration after finding that subcontractors near Milan employed undocumented workers in what investigators described as severely inadequate conditions. One supplier reportedly charged Dior as little as €53 for handbags that retailed for more than €2,000. The disturbing part is not simply that exploitation existed. It is that the brands’ own systems for detecting it failed.
A subsequent Reuters investigation found that some suppliers in Italy had passed social and environmental audits despite police later uncovering exploitative working conditions. The problem was partly buried several layers down the supply chain, where brands had less visibility over subcontractors.
And that “Made in Italy” title can therefore evoke images of an artisan carefully stitching leather in a sunlit Florentine workshop. Yet somewhere further down the chain, the reality can be considerably less romantic.
This is precisely where the fashion industry’s silenced voices become important. We see the model. We see the campaign. We see the immaculate boutique and the beautifully photographed garment. We rarely see the person sewing it. And perhaps consumers do not particularly want to.
This is precisely where the fashion industry’s silenced voices become important. We see the model. We see the campaign. We see the immaculate boutique and the beautifully photographed garment. We rarely see the person sewing it. And perhaps consumers do not particularly want to
There is a certain comfort in not asking where our clothes come from. If we knew that a £6 dress depended upon exhausting working hours, would we still buy it? If we discovered that a £2,600 handbag had passed through workshops where workers were being exploited, would its prestige survive? Then there’s another uncomfortable question: can we really afford to care?
For someone struggling through a cost-of-living crisis, telling them to spend considerably more on ethically produced clothing is hardly a complete solution. Ethical consumption can itself become a luxury. The responsibility therefore cannot rest entirely with consumers who are often given remarkably little information about the people and companies buried within global supply chains.
For someone struggling through a cost-of-living crisis, telling them to spend considerably more on ethically produced clothing is hardly a complete solution
Fashion brands know exactly how to sell us a story. Perhaps they should also tell us the story of everyone who made the clothes.
We seriously should not have to choose between affordability and human dignity. Nor should a label saying “Made in Italy”, “Made in France” or anything else allow us to assume that everything beneath it is automatically ethical.
The real tragedy of fashion is not that we wear beautiful clothes, but rather it is that so many people can make them for us without us ever hearing their voices.
Image credit: Ethan Bodnar via Unsplash

