University criticised for its support of Durham Union Society
By Anoushka Mundey
Durham Student Union, Durham Islamic Society and Durham Students for Palestine have condemned Durham Union society for holding a debate titled “This House Believes Palestinian Leadership is the Greatest Barrier to Peace”. The debate held on Friday 8th November sparked a large protest on the Palace Green which the University eventually moved to Elvet Riverside.
Durham Student Union President, Dan Lonsdale, accused the University of allowing racism “to run rampant” by allowing the debate to go ahead. Mr Lonsdale argued the debate discussed “the extent to which the victims of genocide share the blame for their destruction”.
Separately, Durham Islamic Society condemned the University and Union saying their actions “erodes the values of tolerance, mutual respect and constructive dialogue that should define our academic community.”
Durham Student Union President, Dan Lonsdale, accused the University of allowing racism “to run rampant” by allowing the debate to go ahead.
Durham Union, on their instagram page, reiterated that “any opinions expressed by the speakers we host are their own and are not reflective of the Union views”.
Durham University strongly denies these accusations, stating “As an inclusive community, we do not tolerate antisemitism or anti-Muslim hatred or any form of harassment. We reject outright any public claims made to the contrary by student organisations and student representatives.” They continue to specify that “Some social media posts are offering accounts of the evening that are inaccurate and misleading.”
The controversial debate focused on the broader history of Israel-Palestine conflict and took place against the background of Israel’s current war on Gaza. The debate itself was rescheduled from last term as the University cancelled the event due to the possibility of disorder.
Durham Union voted 92-59 in favour of Palestinian leadership being the “greatest barrier to peace”.
Whilst the debate is divisive, Jerry Li, Durham Union President continues to argue in favour of free speech, stating, on an instagram post, he believes that “dialogue and expression trumps intimidation and silence”.
The University similarly defends free speech, saying it is “committed to upholding freedom of speech within the law and the right to lawful protest.”
However, the SU President questioned the Union’s motivations, instead stating the debate was a “shallow attempt to disguise the tactics of ticket-sales-through-outrage as education for the public good.
“The myth that they offer some kind of vital intellectual service, ‘parliamentary’ in its grandeur, must be definitively laid to rest with this grim charade”.
Durham Union has previously admitted to being in contact with the Free Speech Union (FSU); the FSU recently became involved in University affairs when the SU prohibited the Union from setting up a stall at the fresher’s fair.
In Mr Lonsdale’s statement, he went on to accuse the University of “shield[ing]” the Union from any responsibility for its actions, and that it “continues to pretend that because it doesn’t have control over the DUS, it can’t have any influence on DUS. We all know that this is nonsense”. The Durham Union is an independent, student-run society.
“There’s no point in the University preaching its ‘values’ if they aren’t used to challenge people to be better; this isn’t about control, it’s about leadership. The University abdicated this responsibility.”
Mr Lonsdale condemned the use of police both at the protest, and during the encampment last academic year, he claimed that it is “always a failure”.
“If Durham University maintains the facade that DUS’ activity is none of its business, the least it can do is confirm that no protester is at risk of disciplinary action because of lawful protest taken outside of university activity, and that it will recover student money spent providing private security for the event from the DUS’ trustees.”
Mr Lonsdale condemned the use of police both at the protest, and during the encampment last academic year, he claimed that it is “always a failure”.
Durham University did not respond to Mr Lonsdale’s critiques concerning the use of police.
Image: Anoushka Mundey

