Durham Union breach Equality Act over physically inaccessible debates
By Elliot Burrin
 The Durham Union Society has faced criticism over the inaccessibility of its debating chamber, meaning that students or guests who cannot use stairs cannot participate in many Union Society events.
Andrew Hamilton, a first-year student who is unable to use stairs due to a physical disability, expressed his disappointment with the inaction of the Union Society and Durham University, who own the Pemberton Building, to make the site physically accessible. Currently, there is no stair lift and potential changes to the building are limited by its Grade II listing.
Mr Hamilton has described this as a “disgrace and very disappointing” to Palatinate, as coming to university he was “very interested in debating” but believes he is “unable to participate in the Durham Union Society.”
As the Union Society is a charity, it is obliged to comply with the Equality Act and has a duty to make reasonable adjustments for those with disabilities. In law, this includes a requirement to make adjustments where “a physical feature puts a disabled person at a substantial disadvantage.”
Potential adjustments could include removing or altering the physical feature in question, such as replacing stairs with a ramp or lift, or “providing a reasonable means of avoiding it”, such as holding activities in a more accessible location.
In 2022, the Union Society claimed to submit a request to the University about having a stairlift installed in the Pemberton building. However, an FOI request made by Palatinate found that there is no record of this and the upstairs chamber remains inaccessible.
In 2022, the Union Society claimed to submit a request to the University about having a stairlift installed […] Palatinate found no record of this
Durham University told Palatinate that “Durham University is committed to promoting an accessible environment, while managing the complexity of a historic estate. We have accelerated investment in accessibility improvements across both new construction and renovation projects. Making modifications to heritage assets presents practical challenges that require thorough, ongoing efforts.”
A Palatinate investigation in June found that a third of rooms used for contact hours do not have lift or ramp access. At the time, Durham University said that “for 2024/25, we removed teaching from inaccessible spaces.” The University has undertaken a number of accessibility improvement projects recently, such as pathway repairs, ramp access, and automated doors in some colleges and teaching buildings.
Though the Union Society is not responsible for the maintenance or facilities of the Pemberton Building, this does not waive its duty to create reasonable adjustments under the Equality Act. Mr Hamilton has felt that “so far [the Union Society] have failed to take responsibility, instead washing their hands and blaming others.”
A representative from the Union Society told Mr Hamilton that, whilst they cannot change any physical features of the building, as this falls under the University’s estates team, “commitments have been made as part of our EDI [Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion] plans to ensure issues of accessibility are raised in any future renegotiations between the University and our external trustee board.”
However, the current EDI Plan for the Union Society, which is due to be rewritten by June 2025, does not mention any issues of the building’s inaccessibility. There are no points in the EDI Plan specifically addressing disabilities, aside from the naming of the Disability Representative on the Union Society’s Equalities Committee.
The EDI Plan has identified the aim of “Access and Culture”, stating that the Union Society should “ensure that the Union’s culture is a positive influence on campus and the Union is accessible to all.”
I urge the [Union Society] to take responsibility and address this issue in line with their legal obligations
Andrew Hamilton
“I am happy to put forward any suggestions you may have in the short term, but our capacity as a voluntary student society overseen by a board of charity trustees is unfortunately limited in this area,” the Union Society told Mr Hamilton, expressing that they sometimes use accessible facilities below the main debating chamber, but that “due to our legal arrangements with the University we do not have exclusive access to these rooms.”
Mr Hamilton urged the Union Society to use the downstairs hall as an alternative, but told Palatinate that “upon putting this suggestion to them, I haven’t heard back from them, which is disappointing.”
The Union Society then encouraged Mr Hamilton to get involved in the society, saying “it would be great to see your manifesto in any of our forthcoming elections this term.” Speaking to Palatinate, Mr Hamilton said in response to this: “it is an insult and a slap in the face to be told on the one hand that they understand the physical accessibility issues that exist […] and then to be encouraged to get involved. How am I supposed to [get involved] when I can’t access the debating chamber?”
“Discrimination and exclusion of disabled students has no place in university life,” Mr Hamilton said, “and I urge the [Union Society] to take responsibility and address this issue in line with their legal obligations.”
Palatinate has contacted the Union Society for comment, but they did not provide a response. Â
Image: Anoushka Mundey

