Ukraine and NATO: long term ambitions for membership
By David Verkmann
Amidst increased pressure from the US administration, President Zelensky of Ukraine has said that he is willing to step down from the presidency in return for the country being allowed into NATO.Â
Security guarantees and even talks about NATO are not new in Ukrainian politics. After the dissolution of the Soviet Union, Ukraine had more than a thousand nuclear warheads left in its territory. In the 1994 Budapest memorandum, the country agreed to give up on these weapons in return for an agreement by Russia the UK and the US “to respect Ukraine’s independence and sovereignty in the existing borders”. The country has also had a long history with NATO, it is often understood that the country has oscillated between president more sympathetic to Russia and those more sympathetic to the west. On this journey the most important steps were when in 2008 the Secretary General of NATO declared that while Ukraine and Georgia will not become members then, they will in the future.
On this journey the most important steps were when in 2008 the Secretary General of NATO declared that while Ukraine and Georgia will not become members then, they will in the future.
Outgoing US President George Bush and incoming President Barack Obama also offered words of support for Ukrainian membership of the alliance. After the 2014 Euromaidan protests overthrew the Russia friendly Ukrainian president and a new more western friendly government was elected, talks about closer ties with NATO once again emerged. After the annexation of Crimea by Russia and fighting against separatists in the eastern provinces of Luhansk and Donetsk, calls to join NATO grew even stronger. The country even amended their constitution in 2018 to enshrine an aspiration to joining NATO as a core value of the country.
Through all of this, Ukraine never acquired a Membership Action Plan (MAP), a vehicle through which most states of Western Europe joined the alliance. Having a MAP would have signalled to the country areas in which it needed to implement reforms, as well as providing a clear way into the alliance. After the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine began in February 2022, the alliance agreed that no MAP would be required for Ukraine, and Ukraine handed in its formal application to join in September of 2022. Since the full-scale invasion, there has also continued support by the people of Ukraine for NATO membership, something which never existed in such a sustained matter before.Â
Since the full-scale invasion, there has also continued support by the people of Ukraine for NATO membership, something which never existed in such a sustained matter before.Â
Joining the alliance would require consent from all current members. This step proved a challenge to the last 2 countries to join the alliance, with Sweden and Finland waiting more than a year to secure the support of Turkey and Hungary. Hungary would probably prove one of the most challenging countries to secure the support of for Ukraine. Hungary has used their veto powers in the European Union to prevent further support to Ukraine and to stop sanctions against Russia. Along with Slovakia’s Robert Fico, Hungary’s Viktor Orbán has spoken about how they believe Ukraine joining the alliance would lead to further escalation of the war, which they are unwilling to support.
There is also a general understanding that a country which has active border disputes would not be allowed into the alliance. This is because these states would be considered too fragile for other members to commit defending with their own soldiers. As Ukraine is currently looking unwilling to concede any of the territories claimed by Russia, it is hard to see how they could alleviate this concern in the near future.
Image credit: President of Ukraine via Wikimedia Commons

