Canada as the 51st state: Trudeau caught on hot mic
By David Verkmann
At a recent close door event with business leaders, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau was caught on hot mic saying that the threats coming from the Trump administration of making the country into the 51st state were “a real thing”. These promises have arisen after Mr Trump’s victory in the November election. He has famously promised a retaking of the Panama Canal and taking Greenland as well as
Canada. When asked about the use of force to take these territories, Mr Trump has ruled this out for Canada saying that he would prefer other methods of taking control.
Canada in general is much more liberal than the United States on a multitude of issues, famously having universal healthcare, liberal abortion policies and more stringent gun laws than the USA. Thus, in the electoral politics sense Canada joining the USA would be a big blow to Trump’s political ambitions. So, what makes Trump want to take over the country in the first place? The President has accused Canada of not policing their border enough, saying that large inflows of fentanyl and illegal migrants are coming in from the Northern border. In reality less than 1% of illegal migration and fentanyl coming into the US is thought to come from Canada. Mr Trump has also accused the country of ripping off the US, evidencing this with their large trade deficit with the country. Trade balance however is not evidence of anyone ripping anyone off, it simply is a measure of how much the US buys from Canada contrasted to how much Canada buys from the US. Even if one were to take the trade deficit as problematic, it is unclear why President Trump has not addressed this in his first term, where he was responsible for redesigning the NAFTA trade agreement of the 2 countries into the USMCA, the current trade agreement.
Joining the US is extremely unpopular both with the population as well as among all of the major parties in Canada. Taking over the country without support from the local population and/or the local political establishment would require an extremely large investment from the US, which is exactly what President Trump and Elon Musk are allegedly trying to avoid. It would also violate international law and has come without any historical or cultural justification from Mr Trump. According to Mr Trudeau, Mr Trump is interested in gaining access to Canada’s vast natural resources, such as oil, lumber, coal and gold. The president allegedly thought taking control of the whole country would be the easiest way to access to these.
Joining the US is extremely unpopular both with the population as well as among all of the major parties in Canada
Canada has long been one of the closest partners of the United States both diplomatically as well as economically. It is the largest consumer of US products, and the third largest exporter of goods to the US, only behind China and the European Union. For Canada the US is by far the country’s largest trading partner, with about three quarters of their exports going to the US and about half of their imports coming in from the US. Thus, while a strained relationship would hurt both countries, Canada has way more to lose.
Prime Minister Trudeau has found dealing with the Trump administration a large challenge, his deputy prime minister stepped down in December over her belief that he is not tough enough to deal with Trump. This is what has led to Mr Trudeau announcing his resignation both as Prime Minister and party leader, pending the election of the next leader of the party. It is yet to be seen how the next PM will deal with the hostile rhetoric of the US administration, however it looks extremely likely that they will try to reduce the country’s dependence on US trade, increasing their ties with the UK and Europe. This of course is the exact opposite of what the Trump administration is hoping for.
Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons/Official White House Photo by Benjamin D. Applebaum)

