Kemi Badenoch rows back on Net Zero commitments
By David Verkmann
The leader of the Conservative Party, Kemi Badenoch, has committed her party to extracting all available oil and gas from the North Sea, abandoning what she described as, “Labour’s impossible ideology of net zero by 2050”. Prior to these plans, the net zero by 2050 agreement was something which both the Labour and the Conservative parties agreed upon. Indeed, the original commitment was made by the Conservative Party under the leadership of Theresa May in 2019. This itself followed the cross party supported 2008 Climate Change act which committed to an 80% reduction of emissions by 2050.
While Ms Badenoch frames the issue as one of “untapped national resources”, much of the easily accessible oil and gas was extracted during the six decades since the first North Sea rigs were constructed. What remains lies in smaller, technically challenging fields that are far more expensive to develop. Production from these reserves would only be economically viable if oil prices stayed high for an extended period- something which Mrs Badenoch is unable to guarantee for the private companies that would develop these fields.
”British oil represents a small fraction of global production; it has no impact on the global market price of the resource”
While the Conservatives argue that ending Net Zero targets is crucial, as they drive up consumer energy prices, the reality is quite different. British oil represents a small fraction of global production; it has no impact on the global market price of the resource. Energy prices also would not be reduced in Britain, as natural gas is already the most expensive part of the country’s energy mix. Domestic production is in no way guaranteed to meet domestic demand. Indeed, as much as 80% of the oil extracted from the North Sea is ultimately exported to other countries. Meaning, apart from raising profits for the few private companies extracting oil and other natural resources, the only tangible benefit for taxpayers would be from the increase in tax revenue on oil production.
While oil and gas production is compatible with Net Zero (as emissions can be offset), the Climate Change Committee, the independent advisor of the government says demand must be reduced by 80% by 2050. This means that while oil use is predicted to continue for transportation, and natural gas for electricity generation and heating, the demand must be greatly curtailed. Furthermore, drilling in the North Sea would be deeply counterproductive to the achievement of net zero.
Image: Department for International Trade and The Rt Hon Kemi Badenoch MP/ Simon Dawson / No 10 Downing Street via Wikimedia Commons

