‘Trouble at Topshop’: the rise and fall of a retail empire
By Cressida Black
The recent BBC documentary Trouble at Topshop charts the rise and fall of the iconic brand, focusing on its team of female executives and its tumultuous years under the owner and chairman of Arcadia Group, Sir Phillip Green. The documentary raises an interesting question about the role of businessmen at the top of women’s retail brands and an increasing awareness in the morality of business and conduct in the workplace.
Jane Shepherdson, considered to be something of a legend in the retail industry, became Brand Director of Topshop in 1998 and spearheaded a team of talented young women who transformed Topshop from an unfashionable and dated teen store into a renowned brand. Just six years after Shepherdson’s takeover, Topshop’s annual profit had increased tenfold to £100 million.
Shepherdson credits this success to her creative team who all shared one vision: to respect the customer and “to dress all women, women who really loved fashion”. In the late 90s this vision was certainly radical- female-led teams at the top of women’s retail stores were an anomaly. Many stores were run by businessmen whose primary focus was profit and clothes designs were heavily influenced by the male gaze as male retail owners had little in common with their customers. As Shepherdson and her team were young women, and therefore representative of the consumer market, they were able to create great quality clothes that women wanted to wear. The team’s use of good quality fabric, attention to detail and collaborations with fashion designers like Christopher Kane and shows at London Fashion Week moved the prosperous high-street brand towards the fringes of high fashion.
Female led teams at the top of women’s retail were an anomaly
Retail tycoon Phillip Green bought Topshop in 2002 and just five years later Shepherdson and most of her team resigned. Ashley Armstrong, Retail Editor for The Times, states in the documentary that Green’s primary reasoning for buying Topshop was because “he wanted a retail empire, and because it made him money”, which was in stark contrast to Shepherdson’s aim to create good quality, beautiful clothes for all women.
The retail tycoon’s financial interest became clear when, three years after acquiring Topshop, he paid his family a dividend of £1.2 billion. Not only was it the biggest single dividend in British history, but it also removed vital financial investment from the brand. Green’s disconnect from Shepherdson’s vision sparked her resignation and Green’s belief in cutting costs was felt in in Topshop stores with poor quality clothes and falling sales.
Topshop was marred with scandal following its association with Green. The flagship store on Oxford Street was routinely attacked and protests were held outside during the 2008 financial crash following reports of Green’s apparent tax avoidance. In 2016, BHS, also owned by Green, went into administration with a debt of £1.3 billion with a hollow pension scheme which raised questions about Green’s morality as a businessman.
Finally, in 2019, Green was accused of bullying, racial discrimination and sexual harassment by employees which only cemented his reputation for being immoral and dishonest- traits that were no longer accepted in the realm of British business. As sales declined, the brand could no longer keep up with the competition from online shopping and ultra-fast fashion brands and fell into administration in 2020 during the Covid-19 pandemic.
The Trouble at Topshop documentary demonstrates the importance of female involvement at the top of the women’s retail industry
In charting the rise and fall of the iconic brand, the Trouble at Topshop documentary demonstrates the importance of female involvement at the top of the women’s retail industry, who both represent the customer and are passionate about the clothing they produce. It illustrates the potentially damaging dichotomy between profit-led businessmen who have little interest in fashion and the women’s retail stores that they own.
The documentary further demonstrates the changing shift from the cut-throat and rather unscrupulous methods of business from the late 80s to the early 2000s to a more honest and honourable approach to business which commenced after the 2008 financial crash and had a powerful resurgence after the #MeToo Movement. The now unacceptable behaviour of powerful businessmen was incredibly common during the lucrative years of the 80s, 90s and early 2000s and is only now being addressed.
The documentary brings to light the phenomenon of the power of the consumer which, in the case of Topshop, was the young women who were not afraid to voice their opinion in saying what they wanted, and- more importantly- what they valued. Seemingly, brands who do not listen to the values of their consumers will have no future on the high-street.
Image credit: freestocks via Unsplash

