Netflix’s conundrum: depicting Elizabeth II in ‘The Crown’

By Cressida Black

The next season of The Crown is due to hit our screens this November. This series promises to be even more poignant following the recent death of Queen Elizabeth II. It will surely be a strange adjustment watching actress Imelda Staunton take on the role, with the series itself no doubt influencing the way in which the Queen will be memorialised and remembered. 

The Crown makes for thrilling TV in its dramatisation of royal family’s life, although it hasn’t always stuck to historical fact. Misrepresentation in mainstream media can highly influence public opinion. Should historical dramas like The Crown be allowed to blend fact and fiction for entertainment purposes, especially when it involves the depiction and remembrance of someone as eminent as the late Queen? 

This dramatisation of the royals has done more to promote sympathy and popularity for its members than damage it

Many scenarios depicted in The Crown did not take place and are purely fictional, as many royal historians clarify online after each new season airs. The scenes depicting intimate conversations between royal members are speculation, as no-one can know what truly happened behind the closed doors of Buckingham Palace. Most of these scenes contain historical untruths that are minor and inconsequential. 

If anything, it seems that this dramatisation of the royals has done more to promote sympathy and popularity for its members than damage it. The Queen’s popularity remains the highest of any royal family member.  Journalist Sarah Hughes put this down to the show’s humanisation of the royal family and the Queen’s portrayal as a “steady rock at the centre of an increasingly turbulent world”. In spite of the often blatant inaccuracies in the past few seasons of The Crown, the essence of this portrayal of the Queen has been mostly positive, and has bolstered public interest.

This emotional truth is what lies at the centre of The Crown

However, the next two seasons of The Crown will dramatise some of the most turbulent events of the Queen’s reign in the 1990s. It will explore the breakdown of the marriages of three of the Queen’s children, the various sensational interviews of Princess Diana detailing her mental health struggles and Prince Charles’ affair with Camilla Parker Bowles, as well as Diana’s subsequent death in Paris, which plunged the royal family into crisis. 

The show’s accuracy is more complicated than simply checking the facts. Robert Lacey, the historical consultant for The Crown, stated that “there are two sorts of truth. There is a historical truth, and then there’s the larger truth about the past.” With this classification, it seems that the producers of the show are not trying to purport historic fact but rather, represent a real emotional truth – of the lives and loves, the highs and lows, the tears and the smiles of a real family. This emotional truth is what lies at the centre of The Crown and has made both the show and its depiction of the royal family so popular. Therefore, viewers can expect the next two seasons to portray the Queen, in both scenes of historical fact and in those of fiction, as a constant and unwavering monarch who put her country and her people first, even in times of great personal tragedy. 

Image: Mike Marrah via Unsplash