A tweet, Labour and unity

By Cressida Black

Nadia Whittome’s tweet that Rishi Sunak’s win for prime minister “isn’t a win for Asian representation” sparked heavy criticism towards the Labour Party on social media. The Nottingham East MP was forced to take down the tweet by Labour whips due to the outrage it caused. It has been rumoured that it was Labour Party leader Sir Keir Starmer himself to demand that the tweet be taken down. Whittome’s argument in her tweet stressed that Sunak is “no friend” to “anyone that works for a living” due to his vast wealth and his tax cuts on banks during the drop in living standards in 2021 as Chancellor of the Exchequer. This was dismissed by Starmer in an interview with Sky News who said that Sunak becoming the first British Asian prime minister was “a great thing” and something that the country “should be proud of”. This division in attitude towards the new Conservative prime minister from Labour members has been taken by many news outlets to be further evidence of the disunity of the Labour Party which seems to have been one of its most defining features in recent years and a serious issue for the party’s image. 

With the current political crisis and a string of unsuccessful Conservative prime ministers Starmer has no doubt recognised this political climate as a time of opportunity for the Labour Party’ to prove their readiness for parliamentary power.

While many are concerned that this disunity is a major problem for the future of the Labour Party, this is not necessarily a new phenomenon. Patrick Diamond, the former policy advisor for the New Labour governments in the late 1990s and early 2000s states in his book, Labour’s Civil Wars: How infighting has kept the left from power, that disunity is inherent to the history of the Labour Party since its inception in the 1920s. Diamond states that the very institutional structure of the party itself has been the basis for some of the disunity; the party’s make up of trade unions, parliamentary politicians and grassroots activists are all somewhat disjointed in their economic, political and activist aims. While this certainly lays the foundations for disunity, the conflicting ideological aims seen in recent years over the party’s economic policy, tax and public spending have further exacerbated this image. Divisive personalities, such as Jeremy Corbyn, have accelerated this disunity and have greatly emphasised the schism in the party’s political ideology. Labour’s philosophy has fluctuated in recent years, between aiming to win power in a parliamentary democracy and its role as a social movement.

This disunity is clearly a hindrance to the party. In order to gain support, journalist Anoosh Chakelian states that Labour would need to promote a more united and disciplined approach in order to show the general public that they are fit for office. With the current political crisis and a string of unsuccessful Conservative prime ministers Starmer has no doubt recognised this political climate as a time of opportunity for the Labour Party’ to prove their readiness for parliamentary power. Therefore, for the Labour leader, uniting the party and re-evaluating its image seem to be his primary concern in an effort to gain support from the public and appear ready for government power. 

In September, Starmer stated in an interview with BBC News that “we need a serious person, steering the country confidently and calmly towards a better future” as he attempts to make the party more centrist and clearer in its ideology and economic, political and social ideas. He has already made significant progress in this field, especially in electoral terms. In June last year Ipsos Mori found that Starmer enjoyed a rating of +31%, the joint highest of any leader of the Opposition since polls began in the 1970. 

Therefore, the removal of Whittome’s tweet, however damaging in the short-term, can be viewed as the attempts to unite the Labour Party’s principles and goals in order to appear ready for government. Starmer’s response when asked by Sky News about the removal of Whittome’s tweet exemplifies this. Stating that he “want[s]to be very clear about the stance of the Labour Party on this matter”. Therefore, this event is evidence not of continued disunity, which has always been a rather definitive factor of the Labour Party, but a conscious effort by Starmer to steer the party into a more centrist position. He is attempting to demonstrate that Labour is preparing itself for parliamentary power and is ready to be considered by the nation as the next party in government. 

Image: David Woolfall via Wikimedia Commons