To stay or to go: Newcastle fans remain split over the future of St. James’ Park
By Ben Pawlowski
When ‘Local Hero’ plays over the tannoy and 50,000 Geordies roar on their team in tribal unison, there is nowhere quite like St. James’ Park. The affectionately-nicknamed ‘Cathedral on the Hill’ is steeped in history and atmosphere all the way from 1892 to the present day, having served as home for many an iconic moment and many an iconic player. But three years on from the controversial takeover by Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund (PIF), is the future of the famous old ground in doubt?
Earlier this month, Newcastle United completed the first stage of a stadium expansion feasibility study, with a formal update to proceedings regarding the future of St. James’ Park expected to arrive in the new year. The club’s chief operations officer, Brad Miller, delivered a detailed presentation of the study’s findings to members of the Fan Advisory Board (FAB), a nine-person panel designed to ensure the consideration of supporters within the process, where he promised a “once-in-a-generation investment” in the Toon Army’s facilities.
For Newcastle’s Saudi owners, there is a key decision to be made – whether to stay at St. James’ Park, the club’s spiritual home and source of so much history, or to move elsewhere in the hope of constructing a brand new, purpose-built, state-of-the-art arena which will allow the club to make the next step forward towards its aim of competing with Europe’s elite.
The dilemma is the latest episode in a long and protracted history regarding the stadium’s future. Nestled in the beating heart of Newcastle city centre and just 500 metres from the city’s main train station, efforts to redevelop St. James’ Park have long been hindered by its unique urban geography. The ground is close in proximity to the Leazes Conservation Area, while one of the city’s metro lines runs underground nearby. In addition, the Grade I listed Leazes Terrace, now used as accommodation for postgraduate university students, straddles the stadium’s East Stand, impeding any proposed construction works.
A move away to a new ground, whether in nearby Leazes Park or perhaps south of the River Tyne in neighbouring Gateshead, would likely cost over £3bn, although the true cost might lie in the disquiet it would provoke amongst diehard Newcastle supporters who view St. James’ Park less as a football ground and more as a pilgrimage site.
There have already been several attempts to move away from St. James’ Park throughout Newcastle’s history, such is the difficulty in redeveloping the existing site. In the late 1960s there were two attempts to move, including to a site in Gosforth, until the then-Minister for Sport, Denis Howell, personally approved a planning application to expand the existing ground. In 1995, former chairman Sir John Hall submitted plans for a £65million, 55,000-seater stadium in Leazes Park, an urban green space which lies adjacent to the current site. That application fell apart after local campaigners, under the banner ‘No Business on the Moor’, led a protest campaign which garnered over 36,000 signatures in support, helping to protect a moor on which cows continue to graze to this day.
Nevertheless, redevelopment of St. James’ Park remains an option. Development of the eastern and southern stands could add 10,000 seats to the capacity, which currently stands at 52,350, although that would likely rack up a bill in excess of £1bn, a substantial sum even for the Saudis. A move away to a new ground, whether in nearby Leazes Park or perhaps south of the River Tyne in neighbouring Gateshead, would likely cost over £3bn, although the true cost might lie in the disquiet it would provoke amongst diehard Newcastle supporters who view St. James’ Park less as a football ground and more as a pilgrimage site.
Even Eddie Howe, Newcastle’s current boss, has expressed reservations about upping sticks and abandoning the current stadium. Quizzed by the media over his thoughts on the proposal, Howe said he feared the club would “lose something special” by leaving St. James’ Park, adding that “moving somewhere else feels like a little but of a betrayal”. He is not alone. Newcastle City Council’s newly-elected leader, Labour’s Karen Kilgour, has stated that her preference is to “remain in the city centre”, whilst legendary former midfielder Paul Gascoigne described proposals to move as “stupid”.
Within the Newcastle United fanbase, there is a growing divide amongst those supporters who remain wedded to St. James’ Park as a North East sporting institution and those who feel change is needed to achieve the club’s well-publicised lofty aims. The latter group argue that a new stadium, and an influx of revenue, would give the club more headroom with regards to Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR), allowing greater transfer activity to aid progress on the pitch, whilst also expanding the fanbase to a new generation of proud Geordies. For Newcastle’s Saudi backers, their decision regarding the stadium could define their tenure given that whatever they do will not prove universally popular. One online poll with over 4,000 votes had 52% of fans saying they wanted to stay, whereas 48% expressed a preference to leave. What could possibly go wrong?
Image: Richard Humphrey via Geograph

