Row continues between Durham SU and Union Society
By Anoushka Mundey
The Free Speech Union has sent a letter to Durham University to request that it “deals” with the “militant” Durham Student Union (SU) and SU President Dan Lonsdale after Durham Union Society was not allowed to attend Freshers’ Fair.
The SU denied the Union Society an advertising stall at Fresher’s Fair due to what the SU felt was a lack of equality, diversity, and inclusion. National newspapers ran stories suggesting there had been a “free speech row” at Durham University.
The Role of the Free Speech Union
The Free Speech Union (FSU) was established in 2020 by General-Secretary Toby Young. The body aims to “champion the right of people from all walks of life to express themselves without fear of punishment or persecution”, aiming to “stamp out” “cancel culture”.
It uses political advocacy and public awareness to help those who “feel their speech rights are under threat” and has previously been involved in “no-platforming” disputes at other UK universities.
Mr Young, on behalf of the FSU, wrote a letter to Durham University’s Vice-Chancellor Professor Karen O’Brien after the 2024 fresher’s fair, calling for the University to take legal action against the “militant” SU.
Whilst the letter is not public, the FSU has released an article explaining what was included. Mr Young focuses on the exclusion of the Durham Union from the “key recruitment event of the academic year”, and argues that, under the law, the University should take steps to “ensure freedom of speech within the law is secured for members, students and employees of the establishment and for visiting speakers”.
Mr Young accused the DSU of “unambiguous […] dislike of the society”, citing a former SU officer as describing the society as having “parliamentary-style debates by tuxedo-clad provocateurs”.
“I’m disappointed that the Union not only failed to keep to the terms of its advertising agreement, but is now trying to avoid scrutiny of its failures by kicking up a manufactured drama about free speech.”
SU President, Dan Lonsdale
The article goes on to connect this issue with broader national and parliamentary issues, stressing that “this censorious behaviour by a militant student union, banning a 200 year-old debating society from Fresher’s Fair because it isn’t left-wing enough, wouldn’t be possible if the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act (‘HEFSA’) had been commenced in full by the present government”.
In Mr Lonsdale’s response to the FSU’s letter, published on 9th October, he begins with “You did not address your letter to me, but you sent it to me directly, refer to me throughout your letter, and were bold enough to suggest that I’m both an enemy of free speech and acting in breach of my fiduciary duties and the law”
Regarding Free Speech, he states that “Durham SU believes strongly in freedom of speech and has never, and would never, take any action to disadvantage one of its student groups on the basis of beliefs, opinions, policies, or ideas within the law. There are no examples to the contrary.”
Mr Lonsdale further clarifies, “For the avoidance of doubt: Durham SU does not disagree with any of the lawful beliefs, opinions, policies, or ideas of the Union. The Union trustees have never alleged any such disagreement. You have not identified any such disagreement. I would hope that we all value inclusivity and strive to be anti-racist, and understand that these positions support more people to exercise their freedom of speech; certainly, the Union had said this was their policy, and I supported it. An inclusive debating society on campus has real value for all students and I deeply regret that The Union’ leadership is unable to deliver one.”
Mr Lonsdale referred to the agreement made between the SU and Union in 2020, and the steps taken in 2023.
Finally, the letter to Mr Young, ends with a legal defence, which, as Mr Lonsdale states “You [Mr Young] invite Durham University to exercise control over Durham SU, and me, on the basis of legal provisions you clearly do not understand”.
Durham University continue to request that the SU and the Union “to settle their differences”.
Durham University Spokesperson
Mr Young has previously written articles about Durham student life. In 2020, he published an article in The Critic titled ‘The free speech crisis at Britain’s universities: The massive left-wing bias on campus is putting conservative students at risk’.
Mr Young recounted his experience participating in a debate at the Union, where he was called a paedophile and “tory tosser”, and attempted to frame right-wing young Conservatives as a marginalised and ostracised group within the University, as he states ‘as a Conservative white male, I was aware that life can be pretty tough for people like me on University campuses these days’.
When asked about the Union’s connection with the FSU, Jerry Li, President of the Union told Palatinate that “we are in contact with the Free Speech Union and support their work to promote free speech in universities. The Union is an entity independent of the University, but we work together with the University to ensure freedom of speech is protected and fostered.”
Mr Lonsdale said that “I’m disappointed that the Union not only failed to keep to the terms of its advertising agreement, but is now trying to avoid scrutiny of its failures by kicking up a manufactured drama about free speech.”.
The role of Durham University
Durham University provided with an area for a stall on Palace Green during Matriculation ceremonies, occurring in the cathedral opposite. The University said they made this decision based on “the understanding that Durham Union Society is, as we believe it is, working to deliver the diverse and inclusive community we aspire to right across the University”. They continue to request that the SU and the Union “to settle their differences”.
“[The Durham Union] considers it unfounded for the SU to accuse us of failing to tackle racism when they take no interest at all in the society other than to marginalise it.”
Durham Union President, jerry Li
In response, Mr Lonsdale stressed that Durham University has provided a “disappointing response” to the SU’s treatment of the Union, he stated that the University’s response “problematises Durham SU for opposing racism, and not the Union for failing to tackle racism as it voluntarily promised.”
In response, the University told Palatinate “Durham University Durham University does not tolerate racism in any form” and “Any allegations of racism are taken very seriously and investigated fully.”
Mr Lonsdale continued saying, “the actions of the Union and the inadequate response of Durham University under external pressure shows that only Durham SU is taking this issue seriously.”
He also said he would call for the University’s governing body to investigate any support that it gives to the Union, saying “if our university is giving financial and practical support uncritically to an organisation with a history of perpetuating a hostile culture on campus, our community needs to know. This information must be brought into the open.”
Palatinate understands that the University are not currently directly donating financially to the Union Society.
“The Union acknowledged that it had a real problem with racism, said that it was eager to change, and promised tangible things it would do to show us it was serious about its responsibilities.”
Su President, Dan Lonsdale
The Durham Union and the Student Union
Since Freshers’ Fair, and in response to the SU’s statement, Durham Union President Jerry Li has publicly invited Mr Lonsdale to attend the debate on October 11th. In a public letter, he wrote “Free speech at the Union means giving students an equal footing to the powerful and influential despatch box. The diversity of opinion at the Durham has never been lacking, our membership encompasses many backgrounds and political orientations”.
Whilst Dan Lonsdale hasn’t publicly responded to Mr Li and did not enter the Pemberton Building that Friday, he told Palatinate “The Union acknowledged that it had a real problem with racism, said that it was eager to change, and promised tangible things it would do to show us it was serious about its responsibilities.”
The Union continues to deny allegations of discrimination, the society has said that “considers it unfounded for the SU to accuse us of failing to tackle racism when they take no interest at all in the society other than to marginalise it.”
They continued: “We categorically deny that students are at risk of suffering from racism in the Union. If the SU had taken up our invitation to them to attend the open access debate, they would find the Society to be friendly, inclusive and civil, engaging with our best tradition of free debate. In the past years, we have made great strides in measures to forestall racism, including a new officers’ code of conduct, a streamlined and robust disciplinary process and involving the Equalities officer in every major decision of the society.”
“Our rising rates of membership and record attendance at debates testify to our positive change, the university and colleges have taken an active interest in the affairs of the society, and have been encouraged by what they have seen.”
Image: Anoushka Mundey

