The European Super League: a war won?
By Ben Pawlowski
Remember 18th April 2021? The United Kingdom was in the midst of yet another Covid-19 lockdown, whilst it was – amongst other things – Divock Origi’s 26th birthday. A seemingly innocuous date on paper. In reality, however, this date represented the birth of the European Super League, and the start of perhaps the most tumultuous, unprecedented 48 hours in modern football history.
The announcement by twelve founding clubs of the breakaway ESL’s formation sent the footballing world into a state of shock. Fans were disgusted, commentators revolted, other clubs horrified, and government authorities keen to act, half in a sensible, moral fashion, half in a wild streak of populist fury.
Mass protests, in spite of Covid-19 restrictions, demonstrated the unequivocal consensus of the footballing public – the fat cats in ivory towers would not win.
Ultimately, the mobilisation of mass hysteria and criticism won the battle as the closed-shop, elitist ESL, devoid of sporting merit, developed on an Americanised, ultra-capitalist business model centered on the maximum extraction of profit, was left dead in the water. The battle had been won, but had the war?
Recently, the ESL reared its ugly head once more, rising deep from the depths of the footballing graveyard as its holding company, A22 Sports Management, published an updated manifesto which seeks to right the wrongs of two years ago, and present a sustainable, attractive vision for a new, modernised European footballing model.
Recently, the ESL reared its ugly head once more
The former plan, whereby the founding clubs would hold a permanent place in the league, irrespective of performance, was altered – now, the proposition was for a multi-divisional ‘open competition’ consisting of 60-80 teams, with significant investment in women’s football, and annual solidarity payments to those outside the league.
The new manifesto was also keen to turn the moral tables of the discourse surrounding the competition’s conception.
In a month where Manchester City were charged by their own league for breaking financial rules, and where a club owned by the same people who allegedly murdered Jamal Khashoggi have risen from bottom of the Premier League to the Champions League places within a year – fundamentally on the back of a sportswashing project – how can the current footballing model portray itself as moral and right, and antithetically indict the ESL as immoral, corrupt, and brazenly wrong?
As such, the manifesto highlighted that spending should be based on the generation of resources, rather than injections of capital, while a note that the league would have “respect for European Union law and values” acts as a clear critique of football’s stance on human rights, eminently significant just three months following the conclusion of the World Cup in Qatar. The ESL lost the moral fight last time, but they are cleverer now.
Yet is this new plan bold and cunning enough? The truth is probably not – for now. The Football Supporter’s Association derided the plan as a “walking corpse”, a Trojan Horse for the implementation of the original ESL format, while the European Club Association rejected the rejuvenated proposals as an “alternative reality”.
Ultimately, the memory of April 2021, particularly the disgust of supporters and mass grassroots protest, lingers long in football’s conscience. However, tempting the new proposals may appear, especially in the context of UEFA’s ghastly incoming reforms to the Champions League, the raison d’être of the ESL should never be forgotten.
Football is devoid of its working-class, industrial heartland origins, instead purely a business tool designed to extract capital and divulge shareholders
At its core, it represents a hyper-capitalist vanity project, the brainchild of Wall Street bankers looking for a quick buck. It has little to no footballing merit, certainly not guaranteeing any improvement in entertainment or quality, nor appearing good for the game as a whole.
Nevertheless, despite the ESL’s lacklustre, inherently flawed model that is contingent on financial interests, football needs urgent reform.
Modern football appears to be in a state of perpetual crisis – a merry-go-round that fluctuates between a burgeoning worldwide popularity and grassroots disillusionment. Football is devoid of its working-class, industrial heartland origins, instead purely a business tool designed to extract capital and divulge shareholders.
Fans are priced out by ticket prices, television subscriptions are extortionate, and the sport’s gluttonous economic bubble seems close to bursting point. On the pitch, VAR has diluted the visceral, physical enjoyment of the sport. Racism appears endemic, while corruption and greed mares off the pitch dealings.
The pandemic, ironically, provided a chance to cure football of its ills. That chance was wasted, and now football lies inert, in a state of financial paralysis that, in the long run, threatens the ultimate security and sustainability of the sport as we know it.
The sport undoubtedly needs reform. However, that reform must be fan-led; it must be done for and by the fans. Football is the people’s game, not that of a financial clique, and that war must never be lost.
Image: George M. Groutas via Flickr

