To speak or not to speak: Tennant talks Trump

By Jessica Siddell

David Tennant recently read tweets mocking Donald Trump on the TV programme, ‘Full Frontal With Samantha Bee’. Such open and public ridicule of politicians is becoming increasingly common with high-profile thespians. From Martin Freeman to John Cleese, actors are having their say on politics. However the question still remains as to whether they should. Whilst undoubtedly talented in their field, there seems to be no real reason to justify why their role should extend beyond the theatre, and it is uncertain as to whether they can have any valid contribution to offer to the political sphere. It is one matter if actors are quizzed by journalists on their political allegiances, but another entirely if they impose their beliefs on the public without prompt.

Successful actors have fame and influence as a consequence of their work, whether that is a desired by them or not. I believe this imposes a public role and duty on the actor. Whilst the influence of actors can indubitably be used for the good, particularly considering humanitarian causes, I can’t help but think that it might be dangerous in the political realm. Just as a celebrity is ridiculed for not adhering to the law and being a good role model for young people, they should also consider the effect they have on society with their speech.

Impartiality and objectivity should be key for them, just as it is to someone like the monarch. Some more impressionable or less informed voters may attribute the same weight to a celebrity’s opinion as to facts on a political issue, which simply does not sit well with an educated electorate. With such factors beginning to influence votes, our democracy can have the tendency to be perverted to a simple popularity contest for the actor in question, rather than picking the best policies for the country. It can override our more rational impulses.

Perhaps being able to speak out against career politicians in the public eye is valuable, but there is always the possibility of overstepping the boundary here. There are no guidelines, legal or otherwise, which outline the protocol for such behaviour. Elitism is clearly an issue in contemporary politics, but I am not sure that most actors are best placed to take issue with this. First of all, many of them come from the same privileged background which they criticise in politicians. And secondly, generally, they have few arguments to support, or inclination to follow up any assertions they make in the public eye. This renders any commentary they make fairly redundant.

If we look abroad, we notice a trend, particularly in America, of actors taking on a professional political mantle. From Schwarzenegger to Regan, there has been crossover between politics and theatre, but we must note that they are no longer actively thespians. Furthermore, perhaps there is a similarity between the professions in the required finesse and charisma needed to succeed in both. However, such a similarity gives no authority for actors to question politicians. It just seems to betray more of a need for validation and self-indulgence that causes them to impose their opinions on an unsuspecting populous.

Actors can do great things in order to promote democracy and boost political participation, and this is no way requires them to take an open political leaning. We need to look no further than Tom Hiddleston, who, whilst remaining neutral, simply encouraged his Twitter followers to get involved and vote in the recent EU referendum, tweeting on polling day: “#EUref polling day. Every vote counts. It’s too important. Future in the balance. Listen to the advice of those you trust. Vote.” Such public behaviour epitomises exactly what I think the public role of actors should be – it should be to aid the principles we all stand for, not simply to try to unfairly bias swing voters. They should use their profile for the greater good, not to promote their own interests above and beyond those of our country and world. I think if more actors were to take a leaf out of Hiddleston’s book, we would have considerably higher participation levels and a more politically active youth.

I am not saying that actors should not have political views. Perhaps if they were consistently politically active rather than rearing their heads at pivotal moments, their arguments would be more compelling. However, I am saying that they should approach the political sphere and their commentary upon it with caution. Wariness is key.

If you would like to contribute a reply to this article then please contact stage@palatinate.org.uk or leave a comment on our page. 

Photograph: www.publicdomainpictures.net