Democracy for Our Time
By Maximilien Berthet
No one wants to live in a dictatorship. Scarred by the horrific legacies of Mussolini, Franco, Hitler, Stalin, Ceauşescu, Mao, Sukarno and Pol Pot amongst others, the 20th century has taught us how dearly we should value and appreciate peace and democracy. However, recent occurrences, notably the rise of Donald Trump in the US and Britain’s tumultuous exit from the EU, have called into question the nature of contemporary democracy, and whether or not we understand how to use this most precious tool to its full potential.
Democracy, born of compromise and realism
Voting, an essential aspect of democracy, is vital if a country’s political decisions are to be anchored in the will of its people. The definition of a democratic government is one in which, for practical reasons, power is entrusted to a responsible, elected leader or group of leaders to fulfil – as best they can – the wishes of the people and act in their best interests. Indeed, without appointed leaders, chaos would ensue. If all citizens had to be consulted before a new law was passed, or needed to approve every decision affecting the country or its inhabitants, then the nation’s affairs would grind to a halt under impossibly cumbersome bureaucratic machinery and discord.
Democracy therefore necessarily implies a certain level of hierarchy in decision making, as well as disagreement. Fundamentally, all electors are different: they have distinct personalities, lead radically different lives and face challenges which are completely unlike those of others, all of which contribute to highly personal political preferences and opinions, shaped by a unique set of experiences. It is therefore intrinsically impossible in a democracy to adhere to the wishes of all. However, it is equally undeniable that each member of a democratic society has the unquestionable right to take part in the running of their country, should they so choose: the right to voice their concerns and needs by casting their vote in their own individual way, and to deposit their trust in a proposition or representative of their choice, be it in general elections, local elections, or a referendum.
Freedom of choice: eroded and distorted by our modern lifestyles?
A democracy implies choice. A choice of multiple political candidates to elect, a choice whether or not to adopt a given measure or reform, even a choice whether or not to exert one’s right to vote. A choice implies the making of a decision, which in turn suggests an evaluation of the case for or against a particular proposal.
In order to make a decision, we look to sources of information to feed our reflection, and in this age of technology and social media we need look no further than our mobile phones, tablets and televisions to obtain an extensive picture of the event or figure which has become the most recent focus of our attention. What can easily be forgotten is that many of these outlets of information are biased, offering a deliberately distorted, conveniently incomplete image in order to demonstrate a particular viewpoint.
This is in part a by-product of the age of urgency and quickness in which we live. Our increasingly busy lives mean that many of us only dedicate a few brief instants to learning of the day’s happenings, during the commute to or from work, in snippets at the office or in lectures, or when we turn on the TV when we get home. As such, we rely on digested, summarised, condensed news reports, which omit all the details and sacrifice a balanced perspective in the interest of brevity. Whole news pieces are often condensed to just a few carefully selected words for maximum impact, skilfully arranged into arresting headlines, to dramatise stories which would otherwise be uninteresting, to sell papers or to retain a TV audience.
Stripped of punchy titles and compelling statistics (which, if not false, are often incomplete and poorly explained or put into context), many news items run the risk of becoming dry and mundane, ordinary and uninteresting. Such techniques, an unavoidable part of journalism and politics, are used ever more frequently and extensively as the pallet of sources of information at our disposal becomes increasingly varied, and as we become harder to convince to break from our daily routines to read or listen to the latest headline or news bulletin.
In this sense, the press and the media are hugely powerful. For most people they provide the only link between an event and that person’s knowledge of the event, greatly influencing their perception through the light in which it is reported, by emphasising certain facts at the detriment of others. It follows that the media also largely determine which events we are made aware of in the first place, casting only a select few into the public spotlight. Of course, thankfully, audiences, readers and voters have the right and means to question and delve deeper into what they hear on the news: they can always switch to another TV channel, buy a different newspaper, or search the internet to corroborate or disprove what they have heard or read.
The end of Democracy?
But in practise, many routines are entrenched: most people have a favourite news channel or newspaper. Many people also feel they simply don’t have the time to do further research about an incident, person or organisation, to verify a statistic or fact. Ultimately we often read papers or watch channels which match with and reflect our own views, without searching further, or questioning whether our opinions coincide with reality or not.
In this age of information, with a plethora of facts (or so-called facts), numbers and events thrown at us daily, it can be confusing making sense of it all, especially when different media conduits preach differing or opposing viewpoints. This is made all the more complex given the limited, often minimal, time we dedicate to digesting political matters, even those which directly affect us and those around us.
As a result, we often make up our minds before spending any time reflecting on the true implications of a political decision. We vote a certain way because a candidate or proponent of one side of an argument has shouted the loudest, or used the most compelling statistics, or because our family and friends are voting a certain way, or because we live in a particular community, without truly thinking about what we are doing, choosing not to look further, despite the unprecedented means at our disposal to develop a balanced view before entering the ballot box.
In a sense, then, our choice is often made for us, impressed upon us by a combination of the power and selectivity of the media, and the environment in which we live, rather than being a product of our own deliberation based on hard fact and varied sources. This raises the question of whether what we call a democracy is indeed a democracy, or perhaps what we mean by democracy in the first place.
After centuries of slow yet relentless campaigning and progress, all the ingredients are in place for a democracy. We have the universal suffrage, a true privilege which should be celebrated and used to its full potential. Whether or not we choose to do so is up to us. One thing is certain: our vote can only be meaningful if we set some time aside to collect, review and digest different viewpoints and consider all sides with an open mind, using varied sources, and exerting our critical judgement at every turn, before making a final binding decision. In this way, and this way only, can we ensure the integrity of democracy in our modern times, rekindling the gift bequeathed to us by the Athenians from the hills surrounding the Aegean Sea over two millennia ago.
Photograph by James Beard via Flickr
