An Essay: My thoughts on the EU from an Eastern European Perspective

By Zsófia Borsi

BREXIT has left not just the United Kingdom, but the rest of the world in deep uncertainty regarding several aspects of political as well as personal life; the future of the EU could highly influence international economy and peace. The outcome of the referendum has made one thing very clear – in fact, clearer than any public manifestation of Euroscepticism before –there is a general trend of losing faith in The European Union; whether it can fulfil its fundamental role, to serve the masses by introducing truly needful policies that promote economic and social prosperity. However, this faith will be rather difficult to restore in a Europe where distinct national interests continue to overrule the shared sense of belonging to the EU and people tend to disregard the importance this carries. To see this worries me a lot.

In the past week, I attended a conference in Budapest discussing the problems the EU currently faces as well as its options to reform in order to hold back the tide of Euroscepticism, weakening the Union. Things will and have to change, that has become ultimately clear. Question is, how – in this regard, we can only speculate. At the conference some of the more and less likely scenarios have been discussed, such as the establishment of a ‘two-tier Europe’ (strong political, legal and economic union of the founding member states and a less tight, expandable circle of countries from Central and Eastern Europe) or a ‘re-starting Europe’ (a strongly aligned, more transparent union with only those member countries that agree to give up a greater part of their national sovereignty in order to gain greater global influence) or perhaps an ‘ignorant Europe’ that completely avoids fundamental inner reforms that could realise a stronger and more united Europe and continues to build on false realities.

I am writing this article from a rather personal perspective, shaped by the Eastern European influences of my childhood and present life. Perhaps I grew up in a different political environment and I am not completely familiar with day-to-day British politics, I believe that there is no such thing as a British and a completely separate international perspective on this issue; this is exactly part of what the EU has given us, the young generation of the European Union; we can go and study abroad under the same regulations, get health insurance and granted the eligibility to work almost automatically due to the common standards set by the EU – these things, beyond the fact that they make everyday life a lot less fussy, have a greater importance: they make us feel welcomed. People of the host country are less alienated from you; regardless your accent, the inevitable misunderstandings and cultural differences given national diversity, you begin to feel at home. Having said that, this perspective could be just as much yours as mine – in addition to my Hungarian, national identity I do have an extremely strong European identity that dominates the tone of this article.

Euroscepticism is dangerous.

Brexit, and other possible exits in the future could only win because of self-interested power-politics using the fear and frustration of their people and taking advantage of the EU’s weaknesses; its constant failure to communicate a unified response to the migration crisis and rising threat of terrorism or its powerless control system over national corruption stealing EU money. People need straight-forward answers. We need to stand up against the noticeably increasing influence of Eurosceptics and dispel certain misconceptions regarding the EU presented as the ultimate truth. From my very own perspective, I dare to say that…

 

  1. The EU is democratic.

The rather propagandistic, Eurosceptic and often racist campaigns all over Europe turn to populist arguments and present themselves as the ‘Party of the People’: as if our European communities consisted of an organic society lacking diversity. However, by this claim they completely ignore the existence of any kind of minority.

The EU successfully attempted to achieve a supranational, subsidiary system that democratically coordinates the Union as a whole, battles global issues in an ever globalizing world, while not violating national character, identity or country-specific (but democratic, at least on paper) political structures. It is more democratic than any national parliament can be; it has been designed in a way to take into account the needs of peoples on multiple levels – the individual member states’ (Council of the European Union), the citizens’ of the EU (European Parliament) and the European Union’s as an organization independent of individuals (European Council and Commission).

It does have its own flaws, so as any other democratic system. A recent poll in Germany carried out by Forsa showed that over 80 percent of German population would vote for staying in the EU with no doubt. I think this is important because Germany is arguably one of the most efficiently operating democracies worldwide; people do not need to constantly question whether the laws serve them or not – simply, they see that they work. Shaped by the events of the 20th century, Germany managed to go under a complete democratic transformation and break the chains of illiberal, dictatorial regimes. Comparing EU to a dictatorship is based on empty, superficial and ill-considered arguments, clearly missing out on the second, perhaps even more significant point:

 

  1. The EU is to benefit the ordinary people.

I find this point important to make and it makes me angry to see how certain successfully misleading politicians try to justify the opposite.

Looking at the less developed regions of Europe, in countries where wages for the bottom half of the society has not risen within decades, where the almost sole chance to find a decent job (even with university education) is through nepotism or favouritism, the possibility to go abroad and find a job which can save an entire family from extreme poverty arguably would vanish if it was not for the EU. Those who claim that a country would be better off without EU membership take away the last chance of hope of a financial advancement from those who need it the most. I see a lot of people around me who are concerned about their future at university and fear the loss of Erasmus opportunities to study abroad, rather understandably – if those with high level qualifications worry that their opportunities could narrow, what should be the case for the groups of the society with absolutely no qualifications? They will be basically locked into the inescapable reality of where they were born, without even this chance to break away.

Eurosceptic politicians all over Europe work towards the realization of socially immobile societies and their unquestionable succession of political power – in some Eastern European countries they are already dominating politics but populist, nationalist parties are getting more and more attention all over the West; they are spreading panic about the huge inflow of economic migrants “stealing their jobs” as well as refugees. At the same time, they are not willing to clean toilets for such a low wage rate; they need their immigrants for the least prestigious jobs only.  However, due to the tremendously aging Western societies and low rate of reproduction, foreign professionals are just as much needed – in healthcare, for example.

 

  1. The EU widens our personal and political freedom.

In Hungary, where the current government managed to dismantle any form of credible opposition, controls the media and press therefore fundamentally influences people’s perception of today’s reality and issues, the European Union is perhaps our only safeguard of the last pieces of what might resemble a democracy. Unfortunately, this example is starting to become more or less the norm all over Eastern, and more surprisingly, in Western Europe too (let’s just look at the recent Austrian elections as an example).

The only reason why, I, as a Hungarian girl from the suburbs of Budapest can claim to see ‘the bigger picture’ of what is going on in my country is because of the EU: with every country I travelled to freely and safely, every single foreign friend I made, every story they told, every language I tried to learn, every culture I became part of, I enlarged my identity, my tolerance, my comfort zone and perception of reality. Open-mindedness cannot be achieved in theory. You have to get yourself out there and embrace all the weird, new sensations. The benefits of the EU that shaped me can shape anyone: it makes it possible to regard the World from a multitude of angles; it teaches you how not to hate other cultures but to appreciate their differences, as well as their fusion.

The EU is more than a bureaucratic institution passing laws day by day, but it is also a unique organisation worldwide, fighting for a certain value system on a supranational level. By the support it provides to its member states, remarkably to the East, they are working towards a more income-equal Europe that is certainly in the West’s interest too; it would mean the possibility to open on new markets, to boost international trade and to reduce the amount of shocks to the economy influencing the Eurozone as a whole. This can only be achieved through the creation of a more stable, safer and less polarised Europe. Saying no to this means the necessary constriction of our identity, social and political decadence and no international barriers to racism.

But there is more to the issue than that. Do we have a chance to fight the increasingly worrying global issues that we all face in today’s world – such as global warming, terrorism and migration crisis – in the ‘Europe of nations’? Perhaps on the West, the answer is less evident but on the Eastern side of Europe it is certainly a no. The average individual of countries over there simply do not have the money, the incentive nor the adequate circumstances to make a step towards a more sustainable, less corrupt or more tolerant way of living, because this is not what the national political environment dictates. Here we hate migrants because we do not know who they are; we have never met them, yet we hate them due to the never ending flow of political propaganda fed through all channels of national media, completely in the hands of the ruling elite. If it was not for international laws and regulations, the situation would be even worse, but it could also be much better in a united and more purposeful Europe.

Not to mention the possibility of perhaps even the outburst of a military conflict in the Balkans in the case if Europe fell apart. Countries that are not yet part of the EU, such as Serbia, Bosnia or Albania have a past rich in conflict and hatred. If they no longer have the chance to be part of the Union and enjoy its benefits, they might be left with no braking force to stop local aggression potentially evolving into another Balkan conflict.

 

In terms of looking at the EU-crisis from a constructive point of view, perhaps it is time for the Union to come up with simple but strong, convincing arguments to battle the Eurosceptics’ damaging but indeed very powerful us-them rhetoric. Maintaining a more professional way of communication with the people they serve is the key for winning them. Also, by establishing schools that promote European values and contribute to the creation of a stronger European identity from an early age on could give people a general idea of what ‘those bureaucrats in Brussels’ are actually doing for us.

Photography by Dennis Jarvis via Flickr