Time for new Northern Irish institutions?

By Joe Rossiter

As the DUP and Sinn Féin failed to agree on a deal to govern Northern Ireland, many in the region are asking whether a change in the fundamental principles of government is necessary. Since 1998, when the Good Friday Agreement brought peace after 30 years of violence, Northern Ireland has been governed by power-sharing, where unionists and nationalists must be represented in government. Returning a First Minister and their deputy, therefore, requires the cooperation of both communities, which has not been forthcoming on this occasion. The DUP insists that it will not restore Northern Ireland’s institutions until meaningful change is secured on the Protocol. This has led to calls for systemic reform in the region, with the loudest of these coming from the non-sectarian Alliance party. Led by the popular Naomi Long, Alliance are neither nationalist nor unionist and has had a highly successful electoral performance since 2019. That year, they secured a general election win in North Down, before gaining nine seats in this year’s Assembly election.

Perhaps we are reaching the end of the current era of consociational government

However, the Good Friday Agreement institutionalises the division Alliance are seeking to overcome. The party do not have the same power as nationalist or unionist parties to bring a government into being. Long has called for institutional reform to ensure that those parties that want to form a government can do so, preventing the politically motivated frustrations being seen at present. One could convincingly argue that not being represented in a functioning Executive would be enough to draw the DUP back to the table. Perhaps we are reaching the end of the current era of consociational government; maybe it will be for the best

Image credit: Joe Rossiter