Royally fudged
By Joe Rossiter
Following the death of Queen Elizabeth II, Durham University sent a message to all students addressing the news. Included within was a short paragraph on the late monarch’s visits to Durham which, it must be said, were somewhat limited and mainly part of various Jubilee tours, alongside notice that the bulk of general communication would be stopped during the period of national mourning.
However, the section of the email which drew most ire was that outlining “support” in response to the Queen’s death. The University noted that “this sad news will no doubt impact people in different ways, depending on their views, beliefs and experiences,” before continuing to outline the various outlets available, including college student support, the Counselling and Mental Health Service, and the institution’s chaplains.
Drawing attention to mental health provision is never negative in itself, however the University’s framing of its support speaks to broader flaws in its strategy which detrimentally impact the student experience.
The most obvious issue emphasised by the communication after the Queen’s demise was the University’s understanding of what constitutes a need for proactive support. Whatever a student’s opinions of the monarchy or the Royal Family, it is not unfair to say that the death of a sovereign pales in comparison to the impact of Covid-19 on their university experience, the struggle to find affordable housing in the city or deal with a cost-of-living crisis as winter begins.
Of course, these competing issues have not had the same unified media coverage as the death of Queen Elizabeth, however it should not be beyond the University to deal with many crises at once. After all, this is exactly what students are being forced into.
The University’s approach to mental health is wholly inadequate
To take an example from the summer, Durham County Council offered many student households a £150 council tax rebate (valid even though students are exempt from this levy) as part of the government’s strategy to address the cost-of living crisis. This significant amount of money was given five lines of coverage in the University’s little-read and poorly formatted “Dialogue Student Signposts” email, alongside announcements about early Bill Bryson Library closure and a new system for searching its catalogue.
It was left to Palatinate to relay this message to students, with help from experts on the topic. Guidance for students is available on our website.
What Durham University does not appear to understand is that issues such as these directly contribute to student mental health. When members of the student community are not given adequate access to the already limited outlets of assistance available to them, they are far less able to navigate the crises that these schemes aim to address. It cannot be denied that rising rent and energy bills are linked to the state of student mental health.
When it does come to mental health provision, Durham’s approach is fatally flawed by its reactive approach. In its ‘Mental Health Policy’ document, the University outlines the support available but goes on to say that it “recognises that the students are individual, adult learners, with a responsibility to contribute to their own self-care and to contribute to the quality and wellbeing of the University community.” Further, Durham students are “invited to engage appropriately and professionally with the support available.”
In practice, this means that students are given the responsibility of notifying the University of any struggles they experience. Durham’s approach at this stage is to assert that “it is not a mental health facility nor is it a therapeutic community,” with “limits to the extent of the support that can be provided.”
The University’s approach to mental health is wholly inadequate. Through its hands-off strategy, Durham consistently places burdens on the backs of its community. Though this approach may be the norm across higher education institutions in this country, it cannot be allowed to continue. If the University wants to be a leading academic institution, this must include mental health provision.
Illustration: Rosie Bromiley

