The US Inflation Reduction Act – the starting pistol in the race towards green investment?
By Alex Jennings
Sometimes the health of a relationship is so difficult to assess that the ensuing conflict comes as a shock. But whilst recent dealings between the United States and European Union may have appeared cordial and calm, make no mistake: a trade war could be looming.
The EU is alarmed by the US Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), signed into law by President Biden in August 2022. Whilst it’s debatable whether the legislation actually reduces inflation, what is clear is the bill’s monumental ambition to invest in green industries and tackle climate change.
The IRA will provide about $370 billion of government spending to stimulate domestic clean energy production, electric vehicle manufacturing, emissions reduction and more. Support will take the form of tax credits, loan guarantees and grants, marking a swift and seismic shift towards the green technologies of the future.
Biden will certainly revel in such historic investment which promises to bring great economic benefits to America. But of course, such a giant subsidy for US companies is not untouched by geopolitics: with Washington’s increasingly hawkish stance towards Beijing, the IRA also seeks to significantly favour and bolster domestic supply chains in the hope of further decoupling from the production behemoth that is China.
It is this discrimination against overseas supply and manufacturing which has frustrated America’s allies the most, and which some also argue contravenes World Trade Organisation (WTO) rules. Indeed, there has already been some evidence of European companies switching investment to America in order to take advantage of the new state subsidies and retain fair access to the US market.
But of course, such a giant subsidy for US companies is not untouched by geopolitics … the IRA also seeks to significantly favour and bolster domestic supply chains in the hope of further decoupling from the production behemoth that is China
However, others contend that the EU has long called on America to go much further and faster in tackling climate change, so can hardly complain when the US government does exactly that. If the IRA also acts as a wake-up call for Europe to join the race in the green industrial revolution, some argue that is only a good thing, too.
Yet there are no straightforward comparisons between the US and EU when it comes to state intervention. While the most important tool of the IRA is tax breaks, such powers are nowhere near as simple or effective in the EU – where tax powers are retained by member states.
Moreover, with an internal market consisting of 27 member countries, the EU has historically been steadfast in maintaining a level playing field among wealthier and poorer members, placing strict rules on state aid and competition. Although the EU has been willing to relax such regulations in recent years to respond to the pandemic and the war in Ukraine, further easing restrictions to match the state subsidies being used in the US and China may risk significant damage to the EU’s internal market, with richer nations such as France and Germany providing the most state aid and swallowing up competition.
A more attractive solution could therefore be some kind of European fund, available to all members to finance green industry. Again, though, there is no easy answer to how it will be financed, with many member states averse not only to further fiscal centralisation, but also more borrowing. Instead, there have been suggestions to divert some of the EU’s €800 billion pandemic recovery fund towards more aggressive green industrial investment, as well as introducing many technical reforms to accelerate approvals for green infrastructure and to ensure the workforce is adequately skilled for new jobs.
A more attractive solution could therefore be some kind of European fund, available to all members to finance green industry
However, as the world’s most advanced economies sit on the cusp of a green industrial and technological revolution, perhaps an important question is how beneficial the dawning contest will be for the global economy.
China may have ignored WTO rules over recent decades in its quest for economic supremacy, using the power of the state to shut out competition, but the recent response of the US in the form of the IRA, amongst other action, has fuelled fears around the world of a shift towards a more protectionist approach to realising the industries of the future.
As rivalries emerge in the race for that future, there is certainly an opportunity for the US to cooperate with the EU and other allies in setting the rules for how the new industrial revolution will be allowed to unfold. Yet all signs continue to suggest the US remains committed to its own economic and geopolitical agendas and is largely blithe about its allies becoming collateral damage in the process.
For the EU and other allies of America, including the UK, there may soon be no choice but to respond with their own aggressive interventionist policies or risk being left behind in the contest for future investment. However, if the result is a race to the bottom on regulation and a hardening of protectionist instincts, the spirit of free trade and friendly relations may soon be in peril.
Image: The White House via Wikimedia Commons

