Police ‘Met’ with controversy: can Sir Mark Rowley turn things around for the force?

Content warning: this article contains discussion of rape and sexual assault.

By Alex Jennings

“The police are the public, and the public are the police.” When Sir Robert Peel, the founder of modern policing, said this in 1829, he envisioned a civil force which derived its legitimacy and effectiveness through public support rather than physical duress. Yet the idea of ‘policing by consent’ now seems more futile than ever given the deep sense of disgrace and inadequacy which surrounds British policing today. 

With recorded crime in England and Wales at a 20-year high and public confidence in the local police forces continuing to decline, it’s no surprise that seven police forces in England were placed in special measures by the watchdog last year. Clearly, policing needs significant reform to reverse collapsing trust, and it must surely start with the largest and most prominent failing force: the Metropolitan Police. 

If Sir Mark Rowley, the Met’s recently appointed commissioner, is to turn around the force’s reputation, he will have to begin by enforcing discipline throughout the organisation, driving out the culture of impunity and bigotry which appears to have taken root. 

The murder of Sarah Everard by a serving police officer who was nicknamed “the rapist” by his colleagues; the contempt for the bodies of two women stabbed to death; the strip-search of Child Q. No doubt, the Met has been ridden by scandal for some time. The recent conviction of another officer, David Carrick, on 49 charges relating to more than 80 sexual offences, highlights the appalling behaviour to which the Met has turned a blind eye for too long. In October, it was revealed that more than 1,800 officers and staff had faced multiple allegations of misconduct since 2013, but only 13 of those people were sacked. 

If Sir Mark Rowley, the Met’s recently appointed commissioner, is to turn around the force’s reputation, he will have to begin by enforcing discipline throughout the organisation

What has so far been a trickle of public revelations of criminality in the Met, though, could soon become a stream. Rowley has performing officers, overhauling warned that in the coming weeks and months, two or three Met Police officers per week are expected to appear in court on criminal charges, including cases of violence against women and girls. Evidently, the Met will look worse before it can get better, but Rowley will hope the public can see him confronting the issues and finally purging his force of its toxic culture, in contrast to his predecessor Cressida Dick’s claim that there was only the occasional “bad’un” in the force. 

However, a further problem for the Met is that the majority of good officers are demoralised: a result not just of the scandals which have consumed the force in recent years, but also a consequence of being over-stretched and under- staffed. 

The Met is currently a quasi-national police force, meaning it is constantly balancing the need to deal with the most serious, national and international crimes, including terrorism, with fighting crime in London. If the burden of being a national force could be separated from the day-to-day policing of London, many argue the Met could be more effective in tackling crime and restoring public confidence in policing. 

But if more crimes are to be solved, more officers will be needed too. Like many police forces across the country, the Met is still working to regain the staff lost to austerity measures introduced by the Conservative-led coalition after 2010. Yet when it comes to recruiting police officers, it is often argued that government quotas are unhelpfully forcing the swift employment of substandard candidates, sometimes without adequate vetting of prospective officers. 

If the Met are to improve the quality of their policing, it needs to only hire right-minded people who are up to the job. The Government can also help by making it easier to dismiss poorly the current system which many say sets the bar for expulsion too high. 

If the Met are to improve the quality of their policing, it needs to only hire right-minded people who are up to the job

There are structural changes which could help the Met’s performance as well, with some arguing a return to neighbourhood policing is the most effective way to cut crime and restore public trust. Until 2018, all 32 London boroughs had a chief superintendent in charge of local policing, but many boroughs have since been merged under single police command units. If the Met returned to a more localised strategy, with more decision-making at a local level and a crackdown on the most common crimes such as burglaries, antisocial behaviour and fraud, the force’s standing could soon be put on the road to recovery. 

As Britain’s most high-profile constabulary, the Met should provide an example of modern policing to the rest of the country and lead the way in restoring public confidence in civil law enforcement. Rowley may only be in the initial months of his tenure as commissioner, but for the sake of British policing, he needs to succeed. 

Image: Sir Mark Rowley (Open Government Licence 3 via Wikimedia Commons)