“It is not red or blue, it is green”: How Fox News backed Trump to keep the dollar bills rolling in

By Alex Jennings

More than two years after Donald Trump left the White House, many had hoped his earth-rattling tenure would have by now faded into history. But as Trump’s campaign for a second term gears up, his presidency and its riotous conclusion continue to cause surprising aftershocks, most recently involving America’s most watched cable news network: Fox News.

Dominion Voting Systems is suing Fox News for defamation and seeking $1.6bn in damages after it claims Fox deliberately broadcast false allegations that its devices “flipped” votes from Trump to Biden. The evidence in the case – consisting of thousands of text messages and emails as well as dozens of depositions – reveals how Fox executives and journalists wrestled with how to handle Trump’s election denialism and his attempt to overturn the 2020 election.

Internal emails show that Rupert Murdoch, the company’s founder, became increasingly worried about the channel’s coverage of Trump’s election lies in the weeks after polling day. He denounced the erratic claims made by Trump’s lawyers as “terrible stuff damaging everybody,” and “really crazy,” while even Fox’s star anchors, usually so supportive of Trump on their primetime shows, disparaged the president privately.

Yet despite ridiculing Trump and his arguments of election fraud behind closed doors, Fox executives and journalists apparently realised any attempt to call out the president’s lies publicly was driving away their audience: to keep ratings up, they had to back Trump.

To keep ratings up, [Fox] had to back Trump

As senior figures at Fox News concluded, continuing to support Trump did make commercial sense. Lou Dobbs, a Fox News anchor, testified that broadcasts featuring Sidney Powell, one of Trump’s lawyers who primarily propagated the claims against Dominion, drew audience numbers that were double his programme’s average.

Consistently exceeding $1 billion in yearly operating income, according to estimates by media research group Kagan, Fox News is the most commercially successful cable news network in America and one of the most profitable arms of the Murdoch family empire. But many have long castigated what they see as a business-first approach towards its journalism – building loyal right-wing audiences by promoting forceful and persuasive opinions at the expense of factual and balanced analysis.

However, while the Dominion lawsuit may have revealed evidence to support such allegations of hypocrisy and deceit at Fox News, the raft of published evidence also in some ways contradicts a common perception of the channel. Although Murdoch has long been cast as an all-powerful media magnate, deciding elections and political fortunes as he sees fit, the filings in this case suggest a fear of losing audiences is often the real power behind decisions made at Fox.

To this end, and despite internal disagreements over the approach, Fox News seemed to double down on enforcing the Trump narrative in the weeks after the 2020 election. In one example provided by the lawsuit, after a Fox News reporter tweeted a “fact check” of Trump’s voter fraud claims, primetime anchor Tucker Carlson demanded someone “get her fired.”

Of course, Fox News denies defamation. The cable network has sought to stress the divide between its opinion programmes and news coverage, while legal experts say Dominion will face an uphill battle in proving its case, given the threshold for winning a defamation lawsuit against a journalistic organisation in the US is very high.

America’s cable news business model has so often sacrificed good journalism in favour of indulging audiences with agreeable perspectives

Beyond this particular legal episode, though, many argue the Dominion files remind us how America’s cable news business model has so often sacrificed good journalism in favour of indulging audiences with agreeable perspectives. To a foreign observer, television news studios in the US often resemble ideological echo chambers, with regular panels providing a format to reinforce rather than debate points of view.

Donald Trump’s rise to the presidency and his time in office certainly provided the biggest challenge to journalism in a generation. With his penchant for mistruths and loathsome language, it was frequently said that Trump defied political gravity. Yet this proven ratings winner was often given unchecked airtime on cable news while his voters’ grievances hardly faced proper investigation.

As Trump’s third presidential campaign gathers steam, he certainly looks to be the frontrunner for the Republican nomination. But are newsrooms prepared for Trump 2024?

Good journalism is seldom glamorous and can rarely be achieved from behind a studio desk. Without a return to more on the ground reporting and forensic analysis of America’s problems in the mainstream, many would argue the country’s political polarisation has no chance of being resolved.

Image credit: Steve Bott via Wikimedia Commons