The tyrannies of media representation
By Lynn Ng
Channel Four’s broadcast of “What British Muslims Really Think” has been nothing short of controversial, and while the reasons for this are saddening, it can also be interpreted as a blessing in disguise as it does reveal the problematic representations the media is giving the mass public. At the same time it highlights that segregated groups, British Muslims in this case, are never passive in their subordination and instead actively contest it as best as they can within their restraints in unorganised, informal and everyday ways. The large-scale poll was fraught with statistical manipulations and the results were deliberately selective from the beginning, intended to present an already biased picture of Muslims. Little attention has been given to the problematic justification behind the domination of certain research methods, notably quantitative ones like questionnaires and surveys which were the basis for this poll. This is not to say that these methods are problematic in themselves, but they lack a qualitative complement. Thus it is easy to interpret these data in simplistic terms and come to untrue deductions about their norms and morals. In the first place, surveys only contain questions set by researchers which inevitably contain assumption-laden phrases, such as the question on why British Muslims seem to be “out of line with mainstream society”, which regardless of respondents’ answers, already implies that their morals are inferior. It is such taken-for-granted and unquestioned or normative privilege that “White” Brits have in setting the larger frameworks for the narratives of “Others” that does not receive sufficient acknowledgement. This can be deceiving as we create the illusion that British Muslims are expressing their heartfelt opinions but the tyranny of this is disguised by the very planners of the poll. This methodology, from its inception, was designed as a sort of symbolic violence to maintain “White” dominance.
However, despite the above being said, I make a more contentious and perhaps unsettling argument that we ought to reconsider our own complicit roles in perpetuating the continuous social marginalisation of British Muslims among others. The issue is not as simple as surveys/polls being problematic and non-representative, but perhaps researchers from elite universities and press agencies like ourselves are unconsciously contributing to this hate effect. Over the Easter break, an academic project I was involved in required me and a few group members to head out to Glasgow for a week to explore the lives of the Red Road community whose flats were demolished, and our focus was meant to be on how they contest the stigmatisation of public housing by the council. During this process I came to the realisation that our research endeavours, even those that strive to be qualitative and give our subjects a voice, are also prone to their own tyrannies which is always going to be an obstacle. Even participatory approaches like allowing our subjects to dictate the research agendas is fraught with ethical concerns, for the members of local communities who are available for such purposes are typically not the truly marginalised. Thus it is ironic that despite the amount of time and effort we put into studying and theorising about those less fortunate than us, we never really stop to think about whether this attention we lavish on them might unintentionally contribute to their stigma. We are, after all, unable to discuss certain populations, including British Muslims, in a way that does not evoke difference or dissent. It is woeful that no solution has been reached for this problem, for respondents themselves have expressed that often they do not even wish to participate in our projects, since from its inception we, not they, identify the research questions and justifications. This presents a contradiction to our “feel good” research, but the truth is that we are not the good guys here, and those who express that such polls only serve to heighten existing divisions between “us” and “them” are right in this sense.
It is regretful that we have to acknowledge that no matter how we reformulate our research, it tends to reflect our interests as those in power instead of those we intend to help. As an Asian living in Britain, I might not be able to share the perspective of stigma that British Muslims have, however I do get a sense of where they’re coming from when they make the argument that they are constantly being misrepresented. The hype over how the poll was presented to the public only shows that blaming the methods used is itself deflecting attention from the heart of the matter, which is how these findings are used politically by the relevant agencies. Focusing on the positivist tendency of surveys and their reliance on the neutrality of numbers, if you will, is counterproductive to the interests of marginalised groups. Rather than falling into the trap of binary thinking regarding surveys of Muslims, and assuming that they should not be done, perhaps we should strive for keeping the conditions for any real politics possible. That would be the closest we can get to free democratic expression, and this entails the possibility for any type of views/opinions to be aired, surveys or not. If Durham intends to conduct any such studies in the near future, it is hoped that their planners take such considerations into account before finalising any publications about them.
Image: Wikimedia via Creative Commons
