Take your politics and leave me my voice
By Sofya Grebenkina
It speaks volumes that the current President of a political society wants the student media to be politicized. Yet Jade Azim’s political involvement is not the real issue here. To offer my credentials for this argument as Stage or former Politics Editor is therefore insufficient, and before this begins to sound more like an open letter, I have to however say that for a long time I have sat at the editors’ table and been a part of the vision that Palatinate tries to create. I know what it means to be a part of that editorial board that Azim seeks to change.
The real problem with Azim’s article is obviously that Palatinate is not a political society. It caters to the needs of its readers, aiming for connection rather than alienation of the student population. There’s no need for either institution to become redundant, as long as we leave the universalized campaigning slogans to the political societies and the journalism to the student newspaper.
To believe, for example, that the University ‘is getting away with murder’ is Azim’s right, by all means, but this is what political societies are for – campaigning for a definite position. The ineffective nature of political campaigning and the lack of political involvement among the general student population lies with the responsibility of the individual, first and foremost, and finally with the political societies who seek to persuade people of a certain stance’s validity.
Not only is Palatinate not a political society, but it is also does not strive to emulate its methods. Its unique ‘power’ does not lie in its ability to stifle debate by steam-rolling over opposition to form a consensus. Its ‘power’ lies in the fact that no matter what the editorial board believes in, and thankfully we seek no shared consensus on political issues, any student’s view is given as much space and attention in the paper.
To threaten the editorial board and utilize scaremongering tactics concerning a future lack of readership for Palatinate by praising The Tab’s approach is yet another misunderstanding of our purpose. And no, it is not because Palatinate is somehow ‘above’ The Tab, or whatever else Azim may conjecture about the seemingly ‘snobby’ feel that some of the editorial members give off. It is precisely the diversity in student media that we should value as a university community. There is nothing like being given the option to voice whatever you so wish and in whatever style, with no editorial board breathing down your neck about their political position-of-the-month. Azim’s article is a prime example.
Palatinate remains controversial. This is me, right now, responding to Azim’s provocations. Yet it is only me. Some members of the editorial board may strongly agree with Azim and that is their right. However, as you see, we are not some monolith or homogenous entity with one opinion. The possibility of the individuals on the editorial board being branded with a stance they do not agree with, but are forced to sign onto, is the opposite of democratic representation of student voices.
I think not only of myself, but of other students who may wish to join the board in the future but would feel that their views would be marginalized or side-lined by the overruling political opinion subscribed to by the newspaper. This ‘investigative journalism’ that many of our readers enjoy is only possible if there is a professionally objective editorial board to support and not censor findings, if they don’t match the position held by the newspaper.
Finally Palatinate is not, as Azim terms it, an ‘instrument’ of any kind, insofar that it can be manipulated by some larger political cause. Its regular output does include politically-minded pieces in the Politics and Comment sections. However it is so much more than those two sections or those individual political opinions. It is a forum, a debate with no final vote, and most of all a community. Accuse me of being a traditionalist, if you wish, but if it ain’t broke don’t fix it.
Photograph: Sofya Grebenkina
Jade Azim has written a response to this article on her personal blog, it can be read here.
