The Birthday Party Review: ‘confused and scared, but throughly entertained’

By Matt Brown

The programme of the Hill College Theatre Company’s performance of The Birthday Party warns that the play ‘doesn’t comfortably fit into the theatrical spectrum’. As I was going in to the performance uninitiated in the work of Harold Pinter, I was a little apprehensive as to whether I’d get to grips with his unique ‘comedy of menace’. Fortunately, my first experience of Pinter was a thoroughly enjoyable one, presented by a talented cast with some truly accomplished performances, and I left feeling confused and scared, but thoroughly entertained.

The Birthday Party tells the story of Stanley Webber, a pianist lodging in a seaside boarding house run by a dysfunctional couple, Meg and Petey Boles. Their mundane routine is interrupted by the arrival of two menacing strangers, Goldberg and McCann, who stage a birthday party for Stanley that slowly descends into a nightmarish series of sinister events.

By staging The Birthday Party in the Senate Suite of the Castle, director Katie O’Toole presented herself with a number of challenges. The claustrophobic nature of performing so close to the audience however was fully embraced, leading to some genuinely chilling moments. Small set details like photo-less frames and the relentless ticking of a clock made for an unsettling location for the boarding house. At times the creaking Senate room almost became a character in itself; even the the room’s uneven floor that tilts slightly to the right heightened the sense of disorientation.

Swinging between endearing and unhinged, Elle Morgan-Williams stole every scene with her hilarious performance as the neurotic landlady Meg, delivering multiple belly-laugh moments. Through her solid characterisation, she immersed both herself and the audience into Pinter’s bizarre world and provided some much needed light-relief from the play’s darker themes. Whilst her initial scene with Stanley risked descending into pantomime, Morgan-Williams went on to portray Meg’s naivety and dotty quirks with perfect comic timing, transforming even banal scene changes into moments of great character and humour.

Jake Goldman gave an outstanding performance as the sinister and charismatic Goldberg, demonstrating some very accomplished character acting. His confident mannerisms and Yiddish accent were both consistent and convincing, whilst his fluent transitions between charm and intimidation were truly compelling to watch. George Troop was also suitably menacing in the role of Goldberg’s Irish accomplice, McCann. His bursts of aggression and unflinching stare came across as genuinely threatening, and even made small innocent moments, such as methodically ripping out strips from a newspaper, deeply unsettling. Together, Goldman and Troop really excelled during their quick-fire interrogations of Stanley, in an impressive feat of line-learning and seamless delivery.

Luke Titmuss gave a very competent performance as Stanley, although he could have embraced the calmer moments of his character in the first act, in order to counterpoint his subsequent outbursts. This said, he played Stanley’s denouement in the third act with great conviction and had me genuinely fearful as he literally choked to find words. Talor Hanson’s portrayal of Lulu also deserves a special mention, as she embraced a relatively small part and delivered one of the show’s most emotional performances during the final act. Once again the close proximity of the staging really dialled up the intensity, as subtle details like the visible strangle marks on Lulu’s neck made the play’s harrowing events seem all too real.

Use of lighting was simplistic but very effective, with a clever change of cue to illustrate Stanley’s vision without his glasses, and some very discomforting sequences involving a birthday speech lit by torchlight. Katie O’Toole fully embraced the ability to unsettle the audience in such a small space, with the extended blackout during the shocking end of the second act, leaving the audience transfixed and completely terrified. Sadly, the decision to omit the actor’s final bows felt misjudged, as the audience were itching to shower the cast with the applause that they so deserved, ending the play on an awkward cold note.

I’m fortunate to have received such an enjoyable introduction to the work of Harold Pinter, as The Birthday Party succeeded in juggling both the sinister and the absurd within a naturalistic setting. As exams loom closer and the Durham student theatre scene inevitably goes quiet, I’d urge anyone looking for a final evening out to get their hands on any remaining tickets and witness some truly excellent theatre.

Photograph: Kailin Ra