Discrimination at UK universities

By Lynn Ng

The Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, David Cameron, has publicly announced his disdain for the obvious ethnic and racial discrimination at elite UK universities. Following this, new laws that require universities to publish the breakdown of their intake by ethnic make-up will be put in place soon. This is indeed a firm step forward, as requiring universities to make such data public will alert the public to the severe underrepresentation of ethnic minorities in elite institutions. There is a danger, however, of falling into old traps as we may very likely conflate the presence of such laws with actual racial justice.

I argue that the new laws appear to be somewhat revolutionary, if you like, but may end up doing little for the chances of ethnic minorities of attaining an elite education. History has shown us time and again that the world is increasingly corporate dominated, and many a times even the state finds itself in a subordinate position compared to private firms and their pro-capitalist pressures.

The fact that Oxford has not hesitated to show their disapproval of the new law perhaps reflects wider racism in the UK education system, as much as we might not want to admit it. For their 2014 intake, Oxford only took in 27 black students out of a total intake of more than 2500 students. This sentence itself sends shock waves: for an institution considered as Britain’s epitome of elite education to display such a plain unwillingness to admit black students, ultimately does contribute to a harmful promotion of undesirable stereotypes about particular groups of people.

It seems to me that the new law is inadequate in the sense that it does not do justice to the complexity of ethnic discrimination at UK universities, and this includes our very own Durham. International students not from the European Union may very well fit into the criteria of ethnic minorities, and those of Asian and Chinese ancestry in particular form the largest group. As a Singaporean in Durham, I do get the sense that stereotypes of Asians are at play here, as many tend to associate us with hard work and good grades, contrary to popular portrayals of blacks on the other hand.

I do not wish to ascribe blame to anyone here, but the fact is that in a place like Durham, you have to be non-English to truly understand the presence of such stereotypes in the lives of those who regularly encounter it. Many fellow students laugh it off, saying their comments are harmless jokes, and I agree to the extent that every society has its own “harmless jokes” about other people not like them. But on the other hand, such jokes do a good job of reflecting a society’s general attitude towards minorities and where they ought to stand in their mental hierarchy.

To me it seems that, for both Asians and Blacks at least, both are being racialised but in different ways. The former in a “good” way that gains them higher chances of a place at elite schools, and the latter in a more detrimental way that reduces their chances at upward social mobility. The new law in my opinion may not work well for blacks, and I hate to say this, but I will not be surprised if most people look at a university’s breakdown, feel satisfied with the huge presence of Asians and somehow ignore those of African, Caribbean or related ancestries with darker skin. Ethnic discrimination in universities is not simply a matter of categorising minorities as discriminated by the English system, for within the “minorities” category there are clearly plenty of nuances as well.

In this sense, the new law is very much like Obama’s presidency in the United States. Full of promise and hope for a post-racial future, but ultimately failing to achieve its intended target.  The law may very well continue to subscribe to a cultural hierarchy of ethnicities such that certain ethnicities like the Chinese may be favoured over Africans, something that is ever so common in the US for example.

It is not as simple as forcing schools to disclose the ethnic breakdown of their intake, for it is very easy to use an absolute increase in the intake of minorities to produce an illusion of impartiality. Oxford defends itself by saying that it has already had a 15% increase in intake of ethnic minorities year on year, but if the original number of minorities accepted was not great, this percentage only sounds like a significant improvement without actually being one (eg. 15% increase on 27 black students is rather insignificant). The mode of presentation of the breakdown is also important as numbers can be misleading. More helpful would be if the new laws actually made it compulsory for universities to align their intake such that minorities are given a proportionate representation.

Despite all this, the new law should be interpreted with optimism as it does pledge some promise at reducing ethnic discrimination, no matter how incremental. It may fall into old traps as it pretends to do justice to ethnic minorities, but at least there is such a measure in place and a new platform for minorities to speak up for themselves. Furthermore, the above trends do not just apply to Durham and other UK institutions, but the global order itself. Such structures of ethnic discrimination are internalized in almost every aspect of social life in many countries, and looking at the Ivy League in the US, it is apparent that ethnic discrimination does not just proliferate here. The UK may not have that serious a case of discrimination as to have produced a spate of black shootings, but what elite schools are doing is simply a non-violent way of the same type of discrimination. In this regard, the new laws are baby steps in this marathon.

Illustration: Kenzo Ishida