The Notre Dame Fire: A Year On

By Amana Moore

The streets of Paris in April 2020 are eerily quiet as the city enters its 4th week of Covid-19 induced lockdown, a strikingly different scene to that of a year ago. On 15th April 2019, Parisians filled the streets, transfixed in horror as they – along with millions across the globe – watched the spire of Notre Dame Cathedral, engulfed in flames, come crashing down. The fire, after burning for 9 hours, was finally extinguished; a fight which began as damage prevention had become a desperate attempt to salvage at least the skeleton of this cultural icon. For the French, this building was, according to President Emmanuel Macron, “our history, our literature, the epicentre of our life.” Over 850 years old, Notre Dame Cathedral has been known and loved by countless generations.

Following the fire, Macron optimistically promised to rebuild the church in five years and announced a competition to redesign the spire with a “contemporary touch”. The French government would presumably like to have Notre Dame back in working order for the 2024 Paris Olympics. However, the time and money pumped into saving the cathedral, costs that experts expect to increase, suggest more is at stake than losing a few tourists. 

For many, the burning of Notre Dame …was in some sense a loss of life

In the wake of the fire, almost one billion euros were pledged to rebuild the cathedral, donors including L’OrĂ©al and BNP Paribas promising over ten million euros each. At the time, comparisons were drawn between this mind-blowing response from the world’s richest families and businesses, and the significantly lesser sum raised for the victims of another fire: Grenfell tower, London. How is it that the fire of Notre Dame, which killed a total of zero people compared to the seventy-two lives lost in Grenfell, triggered such an emotive response among both those with a religious faith and none? One could dismiss the Notre Dame fund as a PR stunt by big companies flexing their do-good muscles, or simply an example of the skewed priorities of the world’s elite. Perhaps both hold an element of truth, with some of the biggest donors criticised for failing to cough up a cent of their pledged donations as of June 2019. Yet, this fails to explain the emotional response of French citizens on the ground. One onlooker said, “it’s like losing someone close to you”, while the Mayor of Paris, Anne Hidalgo, recalled prime minister Édouard Phillipe “bursting into tears” at the scene. Clearly for many, the burning of “Notre Dame”, or in English “Our Lady”, was in some sense a loss of life. 

As one of the most famous Catholic churches in the world, many have personal memories of the building. One regular attendee, Michele Chevalier spoke of being “orphaned” by the fire, likening the aftermath to a time of “mourning”. Being currently on my year abroad in Paris, I asked my neighbour, Jeanne, her thoughts on the event and its impact. She recalled the undeniably “spiritual dimension” of the response, describing the beloved cathedral as an inherent part of France’s collective story, having been closed for its Christmas services only once in its history: during the French Revolution.

There is something about this vessel of community which remains essential to life here

The French Revolution established the values of centralism, unity and secularism that France is built on today, and brought about a huge shift in the role of the Church, ratified in the 1905 “Law of Separation of Church and State”. On paper the secularism of France poses a stark contrast to the UK, where Christianity is the state religion, but the moving reaction to Notre Dame’s collapse tells a different story. 

Amid coronavirus, all public spaces have been closed. However, while services are not taking place, many church buildings remain open for people to sit in and pray, something which has been banned in the UK. I’m brought back to my neighbour Jeanne’s description of it as “l’Âme de la France”, that is to say “the soul of France.” There is something about this vessel of community which remains essential to life here, and, though it may take some time, Notre Dame will one day reopen its doors. In Macron’s words, “we have so much to rebuild…we can rebuild, and we will.” 

Image: Nicolas Liponne/NurPhoto via Getty Images