Outtakes – A short story

By Paddy Carey

As a lieutenant you had to know everyone: the guys who would cover you; the guys who would go point and recon; the guys who would kill; and the guys who would piss themselves when an 88 shell landed 30ft away. If you didn’t know who had these qualities; who could do their job, who had the yearning to survive and fight, then you were simply a bad lieutenant. But even if you knew which of your men had these attributes that was not enough. As a lieutenant, you had to understand who was under those brittle, war-moulded, shells of army fatigues, and to do that, knowing whether a private would shit himself as he hit the ground during a shattering barrage was simply not enough.

I connected with my men as much as I could. I dined with them, I trained with them, and I spoke with them. I knew who they were, the jovial boys behind the masks of a discipline-enforcing army routine. One guy, a private, (name was Marty Seitz Jr) was the son of a wealthy Jewish banker on Wall Street who had been hit bad in ’29 with the crash, and he would never shut his mouth about it, saying all kinds of things that his family had to endure after. I can remember his high-pitched New York accent casually saying: “Yeah, you know I am pretty sure ’29 was the worst year of my life.” We had made the landings at Omaha a few days earlier, yet there was not a shred of irony in his voice.

Another soldier, this time a sniper by the name of Peter Jones, discussed first kills with me in a worm-infested foxhole during a sleepless night in Normandy. I told him about the time my pa took me hunting as a boy in the woods near where I lived. It had been some hours before we recognised the deer, slowly trotting between two ferns, oblivious to us. My dad handed the rifle to me and whispered calmly in my trembling ear, “Don’t be scared. Just line it up and pull it, like we did with those cans.” I told this bemused sniper how I had never felt so guilty, so worthless, how when we got home I went up to my room and burst into tears, just for taking a life, a life of a fucking animal, and the fact that my dad had never been prouder. The sniper laughed a lot and then told me his story: “Lined my sight up on his skull …oh boy he just didn’t see it coming…then bam, I zapped him, and I swear I made a Picasso on the wall.” It took me a few days to realise he wasn’t talking about a deer.

Foxholes were where you had these conversations, where instead of killing people you killed time. It was where you waited, sometimes silently, sometimes talking to a buddy, and it was where you waited some more, and just a little bit more. Most people didn’t even know exactly what they were waiting for, just the next event that would hand them that rush of ecstasy that all completed waits provide. Maybe an order to move out, maybe a shelling or maybe contact. But the waiting drove people crazy, made people do stupid things like hallucinating safety.

One time, during the coldest night of the wait in the Ardennes Forest, this stubble-less 19-year-old private wearing nothing but a tatty white vest, army issued trousers and crumbling black boots ran out of cover, out of his foxhole, and into every other foxhole of the company, just showing every guy there a picture his girlfriend had sent him. “Ain’t she just the prettiest girl you ever seen? Ain’t she just perfect? I’m gonna marry that gal and ain’t no war gonna stop me.” His wide, just plain oblivious smile and the sparkle in his youthful eyes is something I have never forgotten.

Nor have I ever forgotten the image of his unblinking face, with that same ignorant smile, lying on some road in Holland. He’d been taking a leak in a bush and some sniper just whacked him, right through the back of the head, just there and then. You couldn’t even really call those deaths “KIA”, and I had trouble even calling them “contact”. A single shot fired, a single target, a single casualty. What an engagement! Real combat was the adrenaline-fuelled dash for cover, when a ’42 opened on you and it was every man for himself, when the shells went off in the foxhole next to you and you thanked God and the German gunner crew for not aiming that little bit more to the right, when you felt just the sheer weight of the air on your shoulders, just pressing down around your sweat infused neck, just hugging the ground and making yourself as small as possible, until you practically became the dirt below you, with nothing but a flimsy wooden fence hiding you from oblivion. And then it was your turn to return fire, to open up on the enemy, to flank around and grenade their position, to radio command and churn out coordinates, to see that grey figure in your iron sights, and to see the burst of red ahead. War was terror. War was a rush.

Each aftermath of an engagement never really felt like a novelty to me. High Command could say that we gained ground, lost ground, got battered around, ran around, ran aground, but for me, there was only really one sole product of an engagement, one guaranteed price to pay: death. It didn’t matter how many people were involved, or how many shots were fired, someone always managed to get themselves hit, and bleed out, or just die instantly. One time after we had a long engagement in some pretty little Norman village, with a pretty little burnt out park, I climbed the stairs up the spire of the church and just surveyed, just looked upon the damage that had been inflicted on mankind and its creations. Torn up bodies were strewn among the church graveyard, a two-tiered levelling of death. Among the streets pock-marked with craters and the bullet chiselled houses, some German, some American, some civilian, all mixed together. Death didn’t discriminate, it wasn’t partisan, and it was independent of side. I had this odd revelation that no matter who we were, in death we were all unified. “Just a lot of meat,” the disgusted Sergeant standing next to me said, “Just a lot of godless fucking meat.”

These sorts of views gave the soul a premature ageing. It wasn’t ageing in the idea of an increased wisdom or an increased appreciation for the wonders of the world; it was an ageing in the sense of a desperate despair, a sense of a greying void in where all joy used to be. You’d see it in all the veterans, and not at all in any of the immediate replacements, but soon enough, after a few weeks of battering from heavy artillery in waist deep holes in the ground, they would adopt the same “I went through hell and back” mental posture that we had assumed months ago. It was heart-breaking to see an 18-year-old who initially addressed us as a “sorry looking bunch” turn to me after a month when his best friend lost a leg and say: “I’m getting too old for this shit, man.”

We saw it in the enemy too. We were walking along a road in Normandy, sometime around dusk with a firebombed village silhouetting us, and passed a surrendered company (or what was left of it) of German soldiers being escorted by some GI’s, and oh man, I had never seen such a ruined cluster of souls. Most had bandages of some sort (often around limbs) with several revealing some bloody head wounds. Others were being carried in hastily built stretchers by their fellow comrades and some required the aid of crutches showing a pained stump below the knee. But what struck me the most wasn’t the horrific injuries inflicted on them, or the fact that the majority of their dwindled number would likely die in the following days, instead it was their eyes: they looked straight through you. They stumbled past us and it was as if we were spirits to them; their gaze penetrated through our translucent bodies and into the fiery landscape ahead. All eyes that had seen too much.

War broke people and then stitched them up again. Sometimes the stitching created emotionless ghouls, who you could fire a .30 Cal at for 30 minutes, shell their position for an hour and then bomb them with B-17’s, and they would be able to venture out of their foxhole completely unfazed and casually ask you for a C-ration. Or, sometimes it created men who seemed their usual self by day, but by night tossed and turned and whimpered in their sleep, or sometimes the stitching failed, and the mind remained broken.

I remember when we were told to dig in for the night in this village near Cannes and I had just settled down in a bottom floor room of a roofless maisonette when I smelt meat cooking. Having not tasted freshly cooked meat for months I began to stalk the origin of the scent. What I discovered was the Sergeant, who had surveyed the damage with me in the spire, spit roasting a stray dog. His explanation went a little something like: “Judge me all you like Lieutenant but I know this war’s just about meat. Meat this, meat that. I reckon if I cook this, I’ll have paid my debt of meat, and I isn’t gonna get whacked.” I looked at him bewildered, hesitating for several seconds. “You wouldn’t understand, Lieutenant”, he said dismissively, and he turned his back on me.

In Holland, an artillery shell landed right next to him. Didn’t explode. A fucking dud. I remember that man grinning and laughing to himself afterwards, just saying to himself “I paid my debt, yes sir I did”. And I remember silently agreeing with him. He had paid his debt.

Image: ‘Hell Fire Corner’ creative commons