The newest Swift scandal

TS

By Will Throp

It’s the stuff headline writers dream of. Taylor Swift, once country music starlet and now pop world sensation, has announced her decision to remove her entire back catalogue from the streaming service Spotify. For an artist whose work focuses so intently upon breakup, it’s certainly fertile ground for journalists to gorge on. Will they ever (ever, ever) get back together? Will she stay, stay, stay? You get the picture. And with her new blockbuster album, ‘1989’, set to break records (at the time of writing, it was on course to becoming the biggest seller since Eminem’s ‘The Eminem Show’), Swift’s choice is certainly a bold one.

The debate has raged on for years now. With U2’s ill-advised mass release of new album, ‘Songs for Innocence’, shipped onto everyone’s iTunes library for free – condemned almost universally as an intrusive, careerist move – there is a renewed focus on the value we place on the music we choose to enjoy.

Let’s look at the figures. A million plays of a song on Spotify will give you a return of £4,000. It’s something, but in Taylor Swift’s world, not exactly earth-shattering – broken down, that equates to $0.007 per play. We might complain that Swift, a multi-millionaire, ought not to be eulogising about receiving such a pitiful amount for her work. After all, she’s still going to sell records, and her revenue will be more than supplemented by live shows and television deals.

But this, I think, misses the point. Music is an incredibly valuable commodity, one that can provide meaning and enrichment to our lives. As Swift herself wrote in the Wall Street Journal last year, “it is my opinion that music should not be free, and my prediction is that individual artists and their labels will someday decide what an album’s price point it. I hope they don’t underestimate themselves or undervalue their art.”

‘All incredibly easy for you to say, Taylor!’ we might exclaim. After all, here is an artist who has played the industry game, and has now, in a sense, outgrown it. With or without Spotify, Swift will continue to be a success, but what about the bands that are just starting out, and need the leg-up that Spotify streaming represents in order to get their work out there?

A valid point, for sure. But we must realise what an important step Taylor Swift has taken, even if it may appear to be a contrived one. If nothing else, it’s indicative that mainstream musicians are finally taking notice of what has become a huge problem for contemporary music consumption. With artists such as Thom Yorke pulling their albums from Spotify (he released his latest solo record ‘Tomorrow’s Modern Boxes’ via BitTorrent), there is a real sense that musicians at the top are beginning to take a stand up against the corporate nature of the music industry.

In a world in which we believe that we ought to be able to access everything we want at the click of a button, it’s important to realise what this says about us as a society. Perhaps, as Taylor Swift is sating, it’s time that we radically re-evaluate the value we place on those things that are most important to us, rather than simply taking the easy, free option.

Image: Big Machine Records