Is music too important to playlist?

JL

By Aaron Bell 

John Lennon is now on Spotify. The words and music of the 20th century’s premier idealist and post-Beatle can now be recommended to people who listened to ‘Paul McCartney’ and then be added to a playlist called “Lazy afternoon” or “Late night lizard” or something.

Regardless of whatever playlist you choose to use, you are going to lose something in the process, like you are squeezing the revolutionary words of “Imagine” through a sieve, only to be left with thin strands that pass over your ears before Spotify shuffles you over to “Get Lucky”.

It is worth appreciating how close to midnight in the playlist-ization of music we are, and it’s basically not a very good thing.

The playlist is the infinitely more portable update of the mixtape, allowing you to share and discover new music, compile misguided collections of affection, and do whatever else people were interested in the eighties. But rather than being the means-to-an-end (such as discovering your new favourite band) it’s become the end unto itself.

There’s a couple of angles. Would it stifle new music? Quite possibly. Would a record label fund one band to produce one album when they can fund twelve bands to produce twelve singles, and people can playlist themselves? There is the flip side that many more new and upcoming artists will get a listen in to their first single, and of course this will be great for new music. However, Spotify doesn’t pay them a huge amount; new bands can’t make much of a living out of it, so only those who can afford to promote themselves will actually see any benefits.

Spotify also impacts the idea of the album as an art form in its own right. Obviously, nobody should tell you how you should or should not listen to music – those guys can slither back to their first edition Led Zeppelin albums – and there’s nothing worse than ‘legislated nostalgia’, meaning “to force a body of

Keep your student discount Spotify, but every once in a while, put on an album, away from the judging eyes of social networks, and listen to it.

people to have memories they do not actually possess” (see Blur’s “Sunday Sunday”), like longing after delivered milk, or the peace and quiet before the mobile phone; the good old days when everyone presumably sat about drinking milk and arguing over the use of the land-line.

Yet if playlists were to take the place of albums, we would quite probably be worse off as we would never experience classic works of art. You would never have reference points of memory, to say “yeah, I was really into OK Computer that time I failed my exam and my dog died”; you would never be able to ask someone what their favourite album is and use their answer to make a snap decision about whether you will like them or not. The most you would be able to do is wonder why nobody follows any of your playlists. I think that world would be an ever-so-slightly worse place.

So what can you do about it? Keep your student discount Spotify, but every once in a while, put on an album, away from the judging eyes of social networks, and listen to it. Then, maybe, together we can start a revolution from our (respective) beds.

Image: Capitol Records