Abenomics: Japan’s post-recovery economy
By Jack Caley
For many years Western economies such as the United States and the United Kingdom have suffered from inflation, and its effects have worsened in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis.
The World Bank states that Consumer Price Inflation (CPI) in 2011 was at 4.5% in the United Kingdom, but averaging last around 2.5% in the last 10 years.
Japan however, despite being one of the largest economic players in the developed world, has suffered from the lesser-known economic evil of deflation for the last few decades. Although consumers have not had to worry about seeing their savings eroded by inflation, due to the existence of deflation, but this has caused many problems for the policy makers of Japan.
Shinzō Abe was re-elected in the 2012 Japanese General elections with his party, the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP), gaining a landslide victory over the Democratic Party of Japan (DPJ).
Many, such as David Pilling, have argued that Mr Abe now has a point to prove with this being his second term as PM, since his first stint being regarded as lacklustre, at best.
He has been branded ‘Abe 2.0’ for his new energised approach and radical ideas, which have been coined ‘Abenomics’, to reinvigorate the Japanese economy and eradicate deflation from the country.
Most were showering the policies with praise last year, such as Richard Harries, who regarded it as the ‘impressive brainchild’ of Mr Abe due to its ‘aggressive monetary policy, flexible fiscal policy and a new growth strategy’.
It has seen the government spend over ¥10 trillion per year on public works projects in order to stimulate the economy through Neo-Keynesian thinking and companies such as Toyota have seen their profits flourish since 2012. In addition to this, unemployment is at a healthy and very low rate amongst developed economies of 4.1%. These are all worthy achievements in the aftermath of the financial crisis.
Deflation was the key feature to address for Mr Abe and broadly it has not been a feature of the economy since his election in 2012, with the World Bank placing CPI at 0% in 2012 and 0.4% in 2013.
Even from the most positive outlook, this is not a wild improvement and could just be seen as a continuation on the course that Japan has been on since the financial crisis; with deflation falling year on year and inflation beginning to occur. The policies appear to be having an impact on the economy, but issues are now arising for the general Japanese public.
One of the key features of these economic policies to eradicate deflation has been the increase of Consumption Tax, which is set for another rise in October 2015 from 8% to 10%. After the initial rise, GDP, perhaps coincidentally, fell by 7.1% and this has led to many further critics of Abenomics.
Professor Seki Obata is one of the leading critics of Abenomics in Japan and believes that this fall is not even the biggest issue with these policies, potentially. The whole concept of ‘reflation’, his perceived goal of these policies, relies on the devaluation of Government bonds, which he argues could lead to a danger of default.
Despite the changes implemented by Mr Abe, Japan is still suffering from below target inflation and splits are emerging from within the Bank of Japan (BoJ) itself.
The main policy issue here is the mass purchase of bonds by a huge Quantitative Easing programme, and on 31st October, the BoJ committed to purchase ¥80 trillion (roughly £438 billion) of government bonds a year. The recent vote to introduce the radical Quantitative easing measures was split 5:4, showing a great lack of consensus for these policies.
The Japanese government itself has shown reluctance to introduce the tax hike scheduled for next year.
The issue of the Consumption Tax rise has become one of the defining factors of Abenomics in recent months, and appears that it could now be the make or break factor for Mr Abe over whether his policies will be judged as successful. He has already and is likely to continue achieving some form of inflation in the Japanese economy, but raising Consumption Tax further is going to impact on the lives and purchasing powers of the ordinary Japanese people.
More and more support is being lost for the tax rise amidst the added problems of a weakening currency and Mr Abe is now showing indecision on the rise. Abenomics began as a broad set of policies but is now finding itself defined by one policy regarding Consumption Tax.
It may be something that is necessary to bring about inflation, but at what cost? This is the question currently being asked by the Japanese population.
