The lost mythology of theatre

By Julia Davies

The history of theatre is in a lot of ways a history of ritual. They are practices equally bound by their devotion to performance, community, and transformation; but while theatre is demarcated by the physical structure of the stage, ritual often manifests in transgressive secrecy. Such is the mythology of Dionysus, the Greek god of wine, festivity, and of theatre itself.

Dionysus was born of Zeus and a mortal woman, who died in childbirth to save his life. Zeus left him to be raised by the nymphs of Mount Nysa, deities who were feminine embodiments of nature, and who would soon become his frenzied followers in the infamous ritual of the Bacchanal. Mythologised as a festival of wild intoxication and pure uninhibited expression, worshippers of Dionysus gathered together; fuelled by unrestrained feasting they celebrated through dancing and music, often devolving into more illicit affairs – sacrifices, for example.

I first came across the mythology of the Bacchanal in a way that completely captured my imagination, a canon event I’m sure, while reading The Secret History by Donna Tartt. Her characters, and the readers alike, are subsumed by the experience: the characters are enthralled by their own participation, but as the reader I was a voyeur, enthralled just by virtue of my own spectatorship.

Worshippers achieved a trance-like state, often induced by psychoactive substances, but ultimately characterised by a surrender to primal spirituality; it was orgiastic, feverish, and theatrical. It was the birth of drama. What Greek theatre wanted from ritual was the element of catharsis. These festivals were highly physical but also deeply psychological, culminating in total emotional release. This purging of emotion was considered to have a cleansing effect, purifying the soul of emotional weight. But this power to harvest inner experience was considered a danger when left to simmer in the hidden crevices of society, precisely because it was constituted by the dissolution of societal conventions themselves.

It was orgiastic, feverish, and theatrical — it was the birth of drama

And so, mythologically of course, theatre was codified to contain this cathartic power and shape it as a force for social betterment. Aristotle believed that through art, as individuals expunge repressed negativity, cathartic experiences could elicit a renewal of the self. Indeed, theatre is a medium of rebirth itself. The ecstasy of performance demands change — it is a retelling of the body, and a retelling of all the performances that came before it.

Thus, the mythic cult of Dionysian ritual flourished within the confines of the stage, bleeding into the floor of the chorus and infecting the audience. But while there was a hierarchical structure to the Greek amphitheatre, the modern notion of the ‘fourth wall’ is a bit of a myth itself. Greek plays favoured direct address and even engaged in debate with people, invoking the audience as storytellers themselves. This obedience to collective experience meant that the effect of theatre exceeded the sum of its parts. Primal human impulses were channelled through structured performances, and the balance between reason and instinct created a new form of knowledge: emotions erupted exponentially, shaping a dialectic of spiritual truth as performers transcended the rational mind.

But fears of thought-conditioning remained. As Western theatre distanced from its mythic origins, new patterns of control emerged. In 1737, the Licensing Act permitted the censorship of all scripts, giving the state the power to shape public discourse and silence criticisms of the government. While this sanitised theatre, this period of theatrical culture still allowed audiences to be performers — stage actors would voice asides, theatre lights remained on, and people would habitually converse during the play. The communal spirit was still alive with fever. Reviewers cited people routinely fainting, rabid queues, and overt crying in the audience.

The theatre appears to us as a high art form, but its power originated in sensation and mythic spirituality

But this is far from the West End we imagine today. Over the weekend, I went to see the movie Hamnet — utterly gut-wrenching. But with the audience submerged in darkness and seriously dedicated to silence, I was unaware of how anyone else was reacting to the film. For most of it, I was honestly convinced I was the only one bawling my eyes out. This hyper-individualised experience of spectatorship led me to repress my emotions, rather than release them.

The same passive audience culture lies in the theatre, where the veil of the fourth wall maintains its tyrannical rule. Audiences are often instructed by performance, rather than engaged in it. The stage conventions of contemporary theatre have fractured what was originally an overwhelming sense of community by scribbling dividing lines between audience and stage, and within the audience itself.

Perhaps the theatre appears to us as a high art form, but its power originated in sensation and mythic spirituality. Can we let ourselves consider what we have lost by making theatre such a highly individualised experience? It seems to me that today, drama plays with the seriousness of society. But when theatre was centred around the seriousness of play, myth itself became a lived experience.

Image: Elena Stead di Quinzio